Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here

Join Over 3 Million Real Estate Investors

Create a free BiggerPockets account to comment, participate, and connect with over 3 million real estate investors.
Use your real name
By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions.
The community here is like my own little personal real estate army that I can depend upon to help me through ANY problems I come across.
Foreclosures
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

Updated over 14 years ago, 05/16/2010

User Stats

23
Posts
0
Votes
Tony Zamberlin
0
Votes |
23
Posts

making offers on reos?

Tony Zamberlin
Posted

i've been told that on reo's banks normally don't take less than 20% of asking price and its a waste of time to go out and offer half of list or below even if the property has been sitting for 5 months to a year or more. is this a good rule to follow?

User Stats

153
Posts
104
Votes
Christopher Davis
  • Real Estate Investor
  • St. Louis, MO
104
Votes |
153
Posts
Christopher Davis
  • Real Estate Investor
  • St. Louis, MO
Replied

I personally make my offers right in the range im willing to pay for that property. This gives me some wiggle room if they counter (reasonably) or if I don't get it and have a chance to make a run at it later. If I do get it then I've saved a few bucks. The risk is that someone offers them asking price which is not uncommon around here on distressed properties in decent neighborhoods.
My opinion , the bank is not usually going to give a huge discount on an already discounted item.
The only way to know to know for sure though is to get some offers in and see what they accept.
Good Luck
Chris

User Stats

1,312
Posts
671
Votes
Jeffrey K.
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Milwaukee, WI
671
Votes |
1,312
Posts
Jeffrey K.
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Milwaukee, WI
Replied

Most of my single REO purchases have been within 10-15% of asking price. I did do a deal where I picked off 6 buildings at once and go them at about 40% off asking. Depends on the bank and how badly they want it off the books.

Rent To Retirement logo
Rent To Retirement
|
Sponsored
Turnkey Rentals 12+ States. SFR, MF & New Builds, High ROI! 3.99% rates, 5% down loans, below market prices across the US! Txt REI to 33777

User Stats

23
Posts
0
Votes
Tony Zamberlin
0
Votes |
23
Posts
Tony Zamberlin
Replied

Ok thanks guys. from what i hear around here its the 20% below asking rule if its been on the market for more than 30 days.

User Stats

2,150
Posts
3,298
Votes
Chris Clothier
Professional Services
Pro Member
#4 Ask About A Real Estate Company Contributor
  • Rental Property Investor
  • memphis, TN
3,298
Votes |
2,150
Posts
Chris Clothier
Professional Services
Pro Member
#4 Ask About A Real Estate Company Contributor
  • Rental Property Investor
  • memphis, TN
Replied

Tony -

We make about 400 offers a month to buy the 20-30 that we actually move to investors. I can tell you that what both Jeff and Christopher said is correct to a point and I will take it one step further. You will never know what price a bank is going to accept on an REO until you make it. If you are not embarrassed by the price, then it is too high. You can never go back and negotiate a buy price down so make sure you make an offer that is going to make you great money first.
We have been doing this for a long time which helps us to buy properties really cheap and we normally purchase below half of listing price.
Get out there and make some offers and be prepared to be laughed at. But when you close on time and get some deals going, you will find the prices get better and your price will be considered a serious offer.

Good Luck -

Chris

business profile image
REI Nation
4.1 stars
35 Reviews

User Stats

23
Posts
0
Votes
Tony Zamberlin
0
Votes |
23
Posts
Tony Zamberlin
Replied

Chris,
Thanks for the reply. So at what percentage below asking are u guys offers normally accepted at? I spoke to a couple other people yesterday and there saying the only time its really a good idea to offer even 30% below the list price is if its been on the market for 6 plus months with no price drops. other than that 10% below on 1st 30 days on market and 25% tops!! below market after that is about all there gonna take if that... let me know your thoughts. sounds like u just blast out a ton of offers and my broker says better to just make like 20 smart offers and get 5 accpeted then 100 and only get 2 accepted....

User Stats

13,450
Posts
8,349
Votes
Steve Babiak
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Audubon, PA
8,349
Votes |
13,450
Posts
Steve Babiak
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Audubon, PA
Replied

Make your offers based on your evaluation of the property, not the price the bank has it listed for. Sometimes the banks get stubborn and are still trying to recover the entire debt amounts owed to them, even when the REO condition is poor. Doesn't make sense, and that's why you only offer what you think it is worth.

How much discount they will accept and how far along in time also varies from bank to bank, so you have to learn them all, or guess, or just keep putting offers in on the same property repeatedly until it sells.

User Stats

17,995
Posts
17,192
Votes
J Scott
Pro Member
  • Investor
  • Sarasota, FL
17,192
Votes |
17,995
Posts
J Scott
Pro Member
  • Investor
  • Sarasota, FL
ModeratorReplied

Like the others have said, offer based on your requirements, not based on the listing price.

Of the 20 or so REOs I've purchased, at least a few have been at 30-40% below list price. Probably close to half of them have been at 50% or more below the original price where I first submitted my offer; for example, it may have been listed at $100K, I offered $50K, got rejected, the bank dropped the price to $70K, I resubmitted my offer, and then got it for $50K or less.

So, make the offer based on what it's worth. If your offer is rejected, submit again after the next price drop (or a couple weeks later). The worst that can happen is that your offer can get rejected.

User Stats

1,067
Posts
84
Votes
Tom C
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Ohio
84
Votes |
1,067
Posts
Tom C
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Ohio
Replied

I usually watch a property sometimes for several months until the price comes down to what I am willing to pay. I then go in and usually offer 1/2 of the listing price. My last REO went from $42 to $36 then to $24K within 6 months. I offered $12 and they countered at $14K plus CC.

I grabbed it. It was a Fannie, they never pay closing cost. Like others have said. It's all based on what you are willing to pay for it, then low ball the offer. Worst they will do is counter.

User Stats

23
Posts
0
Votes
Tony Zamberlin
0
Votes |
23
Posts
Tony Zamberlin
Replied

thanks for all the input guys...It helped me tremendously. I didn't wanna waste time offeing lowball like less than 20-40% below list, but u guys are saying u get them accpeted, so if that the case here goes! I'll lowball the crap out of them..

User Stats

51
Posts
10
Votes
Jaime Vasquez
  • Investor
  • San Antonio, TX
10
Votes |
51
Posts
Jaime Vasquez
  • Investor
  • San Antonio, TX
Replied

Tony, dont even look at what percentage your offering below asking price. Go off your buy formula exclusively.

User Stats

23
Posts
0
Votes
Tony Zamberlin
0
Votes |
23
Posts
Tony Zamberlin
Replied

Ok Thanks. Great!

User Stats

23
Posts
0
Votes
Tony Zamberlin
0
Votes |
23
Posts
Tony Zamberlin
Replied

ok im a little confused. some of you guys are saying be withing 20% of asking and others are saying it dont matter just offer what u can pay end of story!! which is the best rule??

CLOSED Title logo
CLOSED Title
|
Sponsored
CLOSED Title is the Investor Friendly Title Company CLOSED Title, founded by real estate investors. Double closings, assignments, we do it all.

User Stats

17,995
Posts
17,192
Votes
J Scott
Pro Member
  • Investor
  • Sarasota, FL
17,192
Votes |
17,995
Posts
J Scott
Pro Member
  • Investor
  • Sarasota, FL
ModeratorReplied
Originally posted by Tony Zamberlin:
ok im a little confused. some of you guys are saying be withing 20% of asking and others are saying it dont matter just offer what u can pay end of story!! which is the best rule??


There is no "best rule"...you have to do what's right for you...

Some people aren't comfortable making low offers, some people don't think it's worth the time to make lowers when only 1 in 50 is going to get accepted, some people don't have agents who will even put in very low offers, etc.

For those people, offering less than 80% of list price isn't worth the time or effort. So, they employ other strategies to ensure they're getting great deals.

User Stats

23
Posts
0
Votes
Tony Zamberlin
0
Votes |
23
Posts
Tony Zamberlin
Replied

k

User Stats

1,067
Posts
84
Votes
Tom C
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Ohio
84
Votes |
1,067
Posts
Tom C
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Ohio
Replied

Tony,

It's actually pretty simple. It depends what you are doing with it. If it's rent to hold, then you have figure in your cost of purchase, rehab and holding cost based on the rents you can obtain. If you are flipping it, then it's based on your rehab, holding cost and the expected profit. Once you get a couple under your belt, then you will know how to walk in and make an offer. The most important thing is getting in there and make the offer, it's too low, they will kick it back with a counter offer.

User Stats

23
Posts
0
Votes
Tony Zamberlin
0
Votes |
23
Posts
Tony Zamberlin
Replied

k

User Stats

23
Posts
0
Votes
Tony Zamberlin
0
Votes |
23
Posts
Tony Zamberlin
Replied

Ok what do u guys think is a good number or % net to make, or rule to follow when doing a rehab? say under 150k sell price and over 150k sell price? also do u try and make the nicest house in the area and still sell for 10% or so less than the other houses are listed for or above what the other are listed for?

User Stats

1,067
Posts
84
Votes
Tom C
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Ohio
84
Votes |
1,067
Posts
Tom C
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Ohio
Replied

I buy most of the time, the crappiest houses in the best areas. Since I don't sell them, it depends how much holding cost you have into it. Don't get greedy, the most important part is to get rid of it while still making enough profit to justify the work you put into it. IMO.

User Stats

17,995
Posts
17,192
Votes
J Scott
Pro Member
  • Investor
  • Sarasota, FL
17,192
Votes |
17,995
Posts
J Scott
Pro Member
  • Investor
  • Sarasota, FL
ModeratorReplied
Originally posted by Tony Zamberlin:
Ok what do u guys think is a good number or % net to make, or rule to follow when doing a rehab? say under 150k sell price and over 150k sell price?

This really depends on you and your market. Some people would be happy making $10K on a part-time flip of a $200K house...others would want to make $30K on that same flip. Sometimes, it's impossible to consistently make more than 10-15% returns on sale price just because the market in that area just won't support it.

Personally, I like to focus on selling more houses so that I don't have to try to get the most profit out of each. If I can make a quick $20K, I'll take that offer before I hold out for $30K, even if I think the $30K is realistic. A bird in hand...


also do u try and make the nicest house in the area and still sell for 10% or so less than the other houses are listed for or above what the other are listed for?


If you have the nicest house at the lowest comparable price, you should never have too much of a problem finding a buyer...

User Stats

238
Posts
44
Votes
Doug Haisten
  • Mobile, AL
44
Votes |
238
Posts
Doug Haisten
  • Mobile, AL
Replied

Hey guys, so how do you get the listing agent to take a discounted price? I don't want to buy a property just to say i bought one but when I price it at what I think I can turn it around for (and make a modest profit), say 65 - 70% ARV plus repairs, the listing agents don't want to take the offer. Are the listing agent bound to take the offer?

User Stats

17,995
Posts
17,192
Votes
J Scott
Pro Member
  • Investor
  • Sarasota, FL
17,192
Votes |
17,995
Posts
J Scott
Pro Member
  • Investor
  • Sarasota, FL
ModeratorReplied

Doug -

First, it's not the listing agent who decides on whether to sell you an REO property or not...that's the bank's decision.

Legally, listing agents are bound to present any written offers to the seller/bank (unless the seller has previously provided guidelines for what to present and what not to present).

Of course, I know of some listing agents who probably don't submit all offers, as many listing agents believe a low offer is a negative reflection on them. If you can prove they didn't submit an offer, you can report them to the local Board of Realtors or NAR, but proving this can be difficult, and would also likely get you a bad reputation among REO agents.

All that said, make the offers you are comfortable with. If they tend to be very low, just expect that 99% of the time you'll get rejected. But, occasionally, you'll be surprised and will get a counter-offer, at which point you know the bank is motivated and serious.

User Stats

118
Posts
46
Votes
Jaden Ghylin
  • Developer
  • Prior Lake, MN
46
Votes |
118
Posts
Jaden Ghylin
  • Developer
  • Prior Lake, MN
Replied

I've got another question for you all. When you submit offers on REOs are you writing full length Purchase Agreements or are you submitting short 1-2 page offers with price and basic terms? I ask, because I've been forced to write up 18 page purchase agreements for my last few offers and if really limits how many places I'm willing to go through the trouble of offering on. It seems like such a waste of time to do all of that paperwork if the terms and price haven't even been negotiated yet.

Is there a good way to keep it simple and negotiate price and terms before going through all of the PA legwork?

Any thoughts would be appreciated.

-Jaden

BiggerPockets logo
Join Our Private Community for Passive Investors
|
BiggerPockets
Get first-hand insights and real sponsor reviews from other investors

User Stats

13,450
Posts
8,349
Votes
Steve Babiak
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Audubon, PA
8,349
Votes |
13,450
Posts
Steve Babiak
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Audubon, PA
Replied

Jaden,

I agree with you - standard realtor contracts are lengthy - especially when you expect that the offer will be rejected.

How you present an offer will depend on the type of listing and what the seller has instructed the listing agent to do. Often, the listing information will tell you how to present your offers. The experienced REO listing agents will likely have a website that tells you how to present offers to them.

I have posted in this thread what I normally do:
http://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/311/topics/39771-the-art-of-negotiating

User Stats

118
Posts
46
Votes
Jaden Ghylin
  • Developer
  • Prior Lake, MN
46
Votes |
118
Posts
Jaden Ghylin
  • Developer
  • Prior Lake, MN
Replied

Steve,

Do you use your 1 page offer form even if the listing agent is asking for a full purchase agreement for the offer?

Just curious, because so far every listing I've seen wants a full PA with addendums, etc. Seems unreasonable to me. Can I just submit 1 page offers anyway?

-Jaden

User Stats

13,450
Posts
8,349
Votes
Steve Babiak
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Audubon, PA
8,349
Votes |
13,450
Posts
Steve Babiak
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Audubon, PA
Replied

Jaden,

I always tell them the 1 page is an "offer summary" and that upon acceptance the full standard realtor agreement will be executed. Many of these REOs are handled through asset management companies, and there is a web-based portal where the offers are entered; that web portal has no clue what type of paper is in the offer. If rejected, I saved some trees; if accepted, we execute the full documents as promised in the offer summary. And then there is the addendum on top of that.

However, certain loan types and lenders won't do anything without the full agreement, so the 1 page offer doesn't work with those; off the top of my head, HUD listings are in this category.

I suggest you specifically ask whether they are willing to work this way to cut down on amount of paper on rejections.