@Josiah Halverson Greetings Buddy,
So ... being an agent ... I hate what you're doing very much! It gives me zero incentive to truly work with and for you. To me its like dating three girls(or guys) and hoping one of them becomes your Valentine. As an investors agent my goal is volume, assuming we work well together and the first deal is truly a deal, the ideal is that you WILL return. The goal is to cultivate an relationship with you so that we do multiple transactions together and not just one. My goal is have a system in place so that once you say you like a place, I have everything I need and I know everyone on the team I need to know in order to close that thing before you can bat an eye. Also there's nothing that one agent see's that another can not. If its on MLS then its on MLS (Unless agents are working in different areas.)
As an investor, I understand your philosophy; the more people you have out there looking for you, then the more one of them will find what you are looking for. this is true and it makes tons of logical sense. Now allow me to play Devils Advocate: What incentive do I have to give you that deal? Why not give it to one of my other investors who's already done 3 deals with me and tells me I'm one of the few agents he or she works with? Does an agent want to run around showing 10 different clients properties all day hoping someone buys something or does this agent want to get to know exactly what 2 or 3 investors want and feed them all year round because he or she knows they will buy?
I find business to be all about loyalty. If you are going to have multiple agents then at least make sure they work different areas and aren't eating each other out of a living. The thing most buyers never realize is that agents talk ... daily. So 9/10 times we'll eventually know, before you do, that you're working with other agents.
I'd stick with 1 or 2 agents. I'd make sure you two get along first then commit the time to making sure that one agent know exactly what you're looking for. Show this guy or girl what are your must haves and make sure they know what type of investor you are and that they thoroughly understand your strategy.
So that's my advise. I hope it helps ... despite my obvious bias. Let me know what you think. Click the vote button if this helped :D Cheers!