@David Savoy - Austin area school ratings is one of my favorite subjects. Depending on which website or metric you consider, these school districts are constantly flip-flopping rankings, which is a great thing. At the end of the day, we're looking at shades of grey between the *districts*; they're all fairly equal, and all fairly high. When you break it down to an individual school level is where you start to see the nuance. One poorly performing elementary school in a district of 6 schools brings down the average for the entire district; so now a high performing high school gets dinged along with the lesser performing ones. In Georgetown for example (and this isn't the entire reason for your observation, but it is a part of it), there are three high schools, two 'regular' high schools with enrollment of 1500 and 1900, and one 'alternative' high school with enrollment of under 100. I would suggest you consider which school in particular has lower marks and then, don't consider homes zoned for it. Or look around and see if it's an opportunity. Are the homes in that area being bought and updated? Are better educated and move invested parents moving to the area? Buy that house cheap and flip it or lease it while you watch the school rating improve year over year.
I have investors from Singapore who will only purchase in Leander because of it's school ratings, and friends living there who are moving rather than send their kids to one particular school. In Hutto, being zoned to one elementary school is considered the same as winning the lottery and the other is considered 'meh'.
As an investor, consider your clientele. Are you selling or leasing to Apple or Dell execs who want to be 'out of town'? They're buying $650k+ homes and very much care about where their kids are in school. So much so, that they may be looking at private schools and the school zoning counts for nil. Are you selling or leasing to engineers or middle management? They're buying $300k+ homes and also care about the school; so look at the specific schools the property you're considering is zoned for. Are you selling or leasing to medical staff, retail managers, tradesmen, etc? They're buying and leasing at the $250k and under mark, and are *usually* more concerned that its easy to get their kids to school. So look for proximity in that case.
Just my soapbox rant on school ratings.