Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Account Closed

Account Closed has started 11 posts and replied 613 times.

Post: Had no idea Californians were spiritual

Account ClosedPosted
  • Professional
  • Brooklyn, NY
  • Posts 624
  • Votes 147
Originally posted by @Fay Chen:

Also, there are a lot of young professionals moving to LA at least from what I've seen. My friend works at an aerospace company. On average, 2 of his friends move to LA every year. They work in tech/engineering and finance. ..I know that my reality is not the reality for most. Most of my friends are childless professionals like me. And we seem to be enjoying life just fine here in LA.

 Again, same thing here... just vague personal observations unbacked by any credible verifiable fact.

Post: Had no idea Californians were spiritual

Account ClosedPosted
  • Professional
  • Brooklyn, NY
  • Posts 624
  • Votes 147
Originally posted by @Fay Chen:

I think your job report is missing a large source of income -- freelance. For a lot of LAers, freelance is a significant source of income. From producing movies, promoting the new Matcha lounge, to driving for Uber, there is an abundance of freelance work that fits the lifestyle of LAers. And they are not bad paying!

Also, there are a lot of young professionals moving to LA at least from what I've seen. My friend works at an aerospace company. On average, 2 of his friends move to LA every year. They work in tech/engineering and finance. 

I live in the house with roommates. Each room is ~$1000/mon. And I had no trouble filling the rooms with quality people. I usually had to turn away 1-2 qualifying applicants for every listing. They are mostly students pursuing a professional degree and young professionals from all over the country and all over the world. One of my roommates left LA because she didn't like her job, only to find herself back in LA again in a month for 2 interviews! According to her, this is where the jobs are.

I know that my reality is not the reality for most. Most of my friends are childless professionals like me. And we seem to be enjoying life just fine here in LA.

 You kidding right? :) Freelancing?  try telling the lender that you trying to buy this $749,000 house on undocumented freelancing income and you liable to get arrested on the lenders premises much less get a mortgage :)

Post: Had no idea Californians were spiritual

Account ClosedPosted
  • Professional
  • Brooklyn, NY
  • Posts 624
  • Votes 147
Originally posted by @Account Closed:

With respect to the top employment I think we are missing a huge point.  Los Angeles (as with other big cities) draws buyers from around the world.  Foreign nationals will purchase property in order to hold their money in a blue chip investment.  They view it as less risky than their own backyard for a number of factors.  With respect with 28% to 30% of people paying cash-given the average home price is higher than the U.S. average it speaks volumes.  This why you see an uncoupling of wage earners and home sales.  The trend of Los Angeles as someone else mentioned is the lower wage earners are leaving the city as higher wage earners are entering.  

As for "prime locations" worsening- I have yet to witness this.  Instead areas that were considered crime ridden have gentrified to the point that houses are now $1MM and above (Venice echo park silver lake).

 lol... I think your point is also missing the point :)  ; we are for instance talking about how escalating property prices is growing at a rate that far outpaces wage growth of Californias, not foreign entities. Consequently, Californians can't afford a medium sized house based on prevailing wage levels. 

The fact that you have to cite foreign buying activity should also be a supporting argument to this fact. Its like property prices in Vancouver and Toronto, which started to get crazy high that the government there specifically imposed a 15% tax on any transaction by foreigners to control prices. Talk about price discrimination, thought that was ust a marketing thing  :)

If I were to also look into what fraction of the transactions in CA involved foreign nationals, I am sure this might also be exagerated way out of proportion as with other things so far. I haven't seen any concrete numbers yet.

Of course some foreign nationals will view investing just about anywhere in the US less risky because in many countries they face other forms of risk you typically don't face here... country risk, political risk etc... in some cases just someone knowing you have a few millions, heck a few thousands even, parked in the bank is a risk by itself.

I have seen the employment and wage data for LA county specifically and for all industries and sectors. From what I am seeing, the DTI may have to be bumped way up again, way up to 70% range, at which point, there would likely still to be issues.

And since when is police and fire department employees considered low awage earners? In most cities, they typically are able to afford to live where they work, apparently LA is an exception to this. I would almost bet SF is too.

Post: Had no idea Californians were spiritual

Account ClosedPosted
  • Professional
  • Brooklyn, NY
  • Posts 624
  • Votes 147
Originally posted by @Danny Grey:
Originally posted by @Account Closed:
Originally posted by @Chinmay J.:

My unsolicited advice to all Californians is "get out if you can, stay if you must"  That state is going to HELL in a handbasket. 

 Thats harsh

 He's right though. 

 You think so? I can uderstand from an affordability standpoint

Post: Extended stay Hotel/Apartment

Account ClosedPosted
  • Professional
  • Brooklyn, NY
  • Posts 624
  • Votes 147
Originally posted by @Account Closed:
Originally posted by @Michael Hooper:

I assume there is a whole new world of taxes and accounting once I enter into the hotel business?

 lol... thats almost certain; rentals of 30 day or less is a short term rental subject to hotel occupancy tax somewhere in the 5% range

 In Tennessee, based on where specifically (county), that can be up to 6% plus an additional $2.50 per night fee

Post: Extended stay Hotel/Apartment

Account ClosedPosted
  • Professional
  • Brooklyn, NY
  • Posts 624
  • Votes 147
Originally posted by @Michael Hooper:

I assume there is a whole new world of taxes and accounting once I enter into the hotel business?

 lol... thats almost certain; rentals of 30 day or less is a short term rental subject to hotel occupancy tax somewhere in the 5% range

Post: Property owner class action airBNB lawsuit. All owners can join?

Account ClosedPosted
  • Professional
  • Brooklyn, NY
  • Posts 624
  • Votes 147
Originally posted by @Troy Whitney:

LOL Mike. I bought for cash flow off the MLS and the market in parts of Philly skyrocketed in a couple of years. I got lucky. Though I will say when I initially looked at Philly - it seemed like one heck of a deal, especially South Philly - so close to Center City but in many cases an eighth of the price. I wish I'd bought more in those areas - they've been the least hassle and given me the most bang for buck.

Sounds like its worth the occasional headche from the city then? A profit tax of sorts. Thats always the thing with hindsight but somtimes its luck, sometimes its skill.

Post: Had no idea Californians were spiritual

Account ClosedPosted
  • Professional
  • Brooklyn, NY
  • Posts 624
  • Votes 147
Originally posted by @Maksym Logvin:

Someone will explain why live in Los Angeles, if there is no good work? Is it such a great place to live, that everyone there beckons like a magnet? Well, I understand the beginner provincial actresses, but why do they go there?

 Could you clarify the question?

Post: Had no idea Californians were spiritual

Account ClosedPosted
  • Professional
  • Brooklyn, NY
  • Posts 624
  • Votes 147
Originally posted by @Dylan Vargas:

@James Qiu Section 8 has been closed for years. Closed since 2011 in the town my friend lives in per conversation I had with section 8 people 2 days ago. The low income apartments have wait lists a mile long but i am encouraging her to get on the lists anyway. I hope she can understand to move away but needs to get a job lined up first. Trying to help set that up as we speak.

 It is more than a mile for some cities.

Post: Had no idea Californians were spiritual

Account ClosedPosted
  • Professional
  • Brooklyn, NY
  • Posts 624
  • Votes 147
Originally posted by @Matt Mason:

It also works the other way as well.  During 2015 and 2016, there were many people across the country saying the government was lying about the unemployment rate and that there were no jobs.  People here couldn't believe that people could think that since the economy here was booming and there were more job openings than people looking for work.  It was the same when people talked to their friends in Denver, Dallas, Seattle, etc...

It was true that most of the U.S. job growth was in 25 big metro areas, but to people here they would just ask why don't those people just move from their small town to somewhere they could have a job much less a real career.  It doesn't make much sense to people why someone would live in a town with a closed coal mine that has no way of ever opening again and not just move to somewhere with a 21st century economy.

Of course, the reasons can be a little more complex, but this question can be asked just as easily as someone asking why people live in expensive coastal cities.

 I happen to be looking at the employment data for the County of LA as we speak.... of the top 5 employers in LA County, all five are/were all goverment/public sector jobs.... at least as of 2014, and one thing you can be sure about is that especially state government isnt exactly in the 6 figure salary business; the non governmental/public companies that made the list, aren't exactly high tech (except maybe Northrop). I doubt this has changed much. 

There is a reason why as much as two thirds of City of LA employees don't actually live in LA and why only 21 percent of police department or 16% of the fire department actually live in LA -- they can't afford it but these are a substantial amount of the people who will be in the market to buy or rent.

Employer            Employees
County of Los Angeles                  96,500  
Los Angeles Unified School District                  59,600  
City of Los Angeles (including DWP)                  46,900  
University of California, Los Angeles                  44,000  
Federal Government (non-Defense Dept.)                  43,400  
Kaiser Permanente                  36,000  
State of California (non-education)                  29,200  
Northrop Grumman Corp.                  17,000  
Target Corp.                  15,000  
Providence Health & Services                  15,000