Hi Alison,
I have not bought a property yet and I'm in the analysis phase too. But here's my 2 cents. I like to be very conservative in my analysis. I see you have repairs, capex and vacancy at 2%. This house was built in 1928, IMO I use 10% across the board just because you never know what will come up in a house that old. That being said, looking for cash flowing properties in our area is hard because everything is so expensive and a lot times they just don't cash flow.
I plan on buying a multi family in the new year but I've been running lots of numbers, it's great practice.
For me, I need to find something off market in order to be able to make it cash flow I think, at least that's what I'm going to try to do. I want to live in the property I will buy but I still run the numbers as if it was fully rented out.
Are you using Rentometer to calculate your rents? I find that really helpful. I also use SpotCrime to check on crime in the area because I want to live there and feel safe.
I'm new, but if I can help you out in anyway, let me know.
Good Luck!
Lesley