@Mark W Carpenter
I hear ya; been there.
Main issue isn't competition. It's the list itself. All the usual list everyone tries to target (Absentee, pre-foreclosure, tax delinquent, code violation, probate) only assumes motivation, so ppl are hoping they find an owner who are motivated to sell, spending hundreds/thousands of dollars every month.
Everybody's busy trying to figure out the "best marketing method"; how the font should look, what color envelop to use, whether to do voicemail drops, cold call, or if it's online marketing, how to do a proper PPC campaign, optimize their site for SEO purposes, etc. At my peak, I spent $28,000/yr on yellow letter marketing.
Even if you had zero competition in your market, out of the, let's say 1000 ppl you market to, only a small percentage of ppl are ready to do something with their property.
Compare that to owners who just had fire. The incident just made them motivated to do something with their property.
There are 5 exit strategies with fire damaged properties:
1) Fix & Flip
2) Develop
3) Assignment of contract
4) Restoration & Renovation Job
5) Refer out Restoration/Renovation Job
This was why I started getting into this niche, and figured out how to aggregate info on properties that were having fires, real time.
I would skip trace, and call them. My ratios went from sending out about 2000~25000 letters/mth to get 1-2% response rate, to calling up fire damaged property owners, talking to 10 and getting 1-3 actual appointments. I was able to repeat these ratios, not cuz of how good I was on the phone, but because of the type of owners I was targeting.
This is an actual list of properties in NYC that had fire. What percentage of those owners were motivated to do something? 99%.
(Moderator Note: Image removed for addresses.)
It's like having a mechanic shop, where I was having 60, 70, 80 cars that just happen to have a flat tire as they were driving by my shop. Not a hard sell when the need is there, and it's an immediate need.
I can go anywhere in the country call these ppl and get appointments within a day or two. (I compile this data in about 40 cities, getting ready to roll out nationwide coverage). I don't have to wait to perfect my direct mail campaign, optimize my site for SEO, etc.