Originally posted by @Erica Larence-Penna:
@John Collins thank you! Market rents in the area are about $1,200, so we expect to get $2,400, but cash flow around $700.
OK, so depending on whether you are doing some of the reno as opposed to contractor doing all , a couple places where you can save thousands:
1. Redoing the kitchen cabinets instead of new ones. Sand, prime, sand, paint, sand, paint with a spray gun and premium paint. Soft close drawer hinges aren't expensive either.
2. Google "refinish tub and tile" and see if you have any good reviews in your area. It's an amazing job but you have to tell your tenants not to use bleach when cleaning afterwards. However if there's any kind of mold then I would redo it from scratch.
3. Don't think it's worth $5,000 refinishing these hardwoods as opposed to getting new LVP (waterproof everywhere) or engineered wood (not waterproof, need tile in water areas). They don't look that great, and there are plenty of places that sell flooring and installation for a better price than buying separate. I have put in premium engineered in upscale places with install for $4.5-5 sq/ft with a discount as inventory was close to finished. LVP is cheaper and better for rentals where tenant isn't that diligent.
For the counters, I would do a grade 1 to 3 (it goes up to grade 8) granite, cost effective and last forever.