Originally posted by @Brian Beck:
@John Collins
I cant recommend from first hand experience but I know others who I've worked with have recommended DyeBrick. It's a tinting/staining product made specific for bricks.
With regards to painting, all the big companies have a product designed for brick. When painting brick you really want to make certain you a) prep and clean the surface so the paint adheres properly and b) make certain you use a breathable paint that wont trap the moisture inside the brick/building envelope behind the paint. If you go to a Sherwin William's any of their staff should be able to help you with this, they may offer a staining product too at this point.
Hope that helps a little, if you do stain let me know how it turns out, I'd love to see before/after. Best of luck!
Here is the priority of what I like
1. Paint
2. Plaster
3.German schmear
4. Stain (boring)
However, this is a large house in a gated community with a very finicky HOA about making modifications to the original build. I doubt they will let me cover the grout/mortar lines between brick with another color. I have submitted proposals and it will be reviewed in the coming week. The house next to it is a plaster that was well done, but that's how it looked when it was built. Hoping once things are approved I can get started and post pics of progress.
Thank you for the recommendation, it is crazy how no American companies stock Brick Stain (everything I have seen is Canada or international). I will order old english red and tudor brown for sampling. Did you have any issues with time for shipping or ridiculous rates?