Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: John Collins

John Collins has started 45 posts and replied 311 times.

Originally posted by @Jonathon Weber:

OP, what you stated to do in the original post is not a smart way to go about it. If you go with homes, buy one at a time, get it cash flowing and then buy another.  What you describe is throwing all of your money to the wall and hoping it pans out. 

I would recommend multifamily with $500k. 

Do you have any examples of the type of multifamily you can get in that range? Just seems low to me...

I know a few of these communities near Santa Clarita and the ones coming up north of that .. but you are a bit overconfident of the vacancy rates in new developments. There is only so much money people have and only so far they are willing to live away from work. To better assess the demand, why not start with fewer properties and go from there? There's also resistance (and for good reason) from environmentalists and those who see what overdevelopment does in the face of mother nature as california keeps expanding into wildfire and earthquake territory. People struggling aren't just going to move and jump into a high rental home. Again, not a bad idea, but also not the best thing to jump into with 10 sfh's at once. 

Originally posted by @Pratik P.:

Value add multifamily allllllll the way. 

Buy>improve>hold>sell (1031)>repeat.

You won't cashflow with 10 500k houses renting at 3k. Also, I highly doubt banks will give you 10 mortgages with your history. 

Can you give an example of the type of multifamily you would look at in the 500k range? 

Post: Downdraft stoves gone out of style?

John CollinsPosted
  • Investor
  • Tx, Ga
  • Posts 313
  • Votes 337

Need a new stove put in.

The existing system is downdraft but I don't see anything decent below $1400 and options are limited. I know they are less efficient than the overhead fans but this house was installed with one a couple decades ago.

For going with a range hood, the cost is $200, installation is $500... which is fine, but ductwork will have to be put in and creatively. The ceiling above just is a no go zone from 3 different contractors and I've looked around with a flashlight myself. It has to be done over the island (island range hood) as otherwise we have to tear out cabinets/sink adding more work. The quotes average around $1800. So with a new stove, it's $3k. 

Is the extra $1600 worth it , or is a downdraft good enough? 

Post: before-and-after home remodeling costs...your market?

John CollinsPosted
  • Investor
  • Tx, Ga
  • Posts 313
  • Votes 337

This is too broad and too general. there are so many details that change numbers drastically.

For example, take the kitchen. What appliances were changed? Was tile put on tile or was the existing tile demolished? Were the cabinets painted over, resurfaced or changed altogether? Did plumbing and gas connections have to be rerouted? If you had to switch to a range hood was there sufficient space for duct work? Entry and exit points? 

So the short answer is do your homework , get all the prices for your first remodel, and use that as a base for further remodels. 

Post: Question about contractors

John CollinsPosted
  • Investor
  • Tx, Ga
  • Posts 313
  • Votes 337

As a newbie? Have a friend who is a realtor that has been in the business for over a decade. They can spot the major issues based on inspection reports and even an eye test. 

I have wasted tooo much time with contractors each putting their own spin on things, only to be directly contradicted by another, yadda yadda. Have someone who can see things from the outside looking in, even if you have to pay them initially it is more valuable with money saved in long run. I only go to them when I have details of what I want exactly and at what price point is acceptable. Eventually Labor is time and time is money .

I learnt a ton after doing my first redo (did most all of the work except countertop and shower glass install). For 6 weeks (summer when I wasn't working) I watched DIY shows and went to the property and had at it. Friends helped on occasion. Saved 20k, Put 30k into it, saw it's value increase by a 100k and now has held steady at a value of 150k above purchase. 

Post: Quartz countertops to raise rental value?

John CollinsPosted
  • Investor
  • Tx, Ga
  • Posts 313
  • Votes 337
Originally posted by @Jim Goebel:

@John Collins

Hi there,

We had a Bosnian neighbor that was in the business and I think we paid something like $1800 for labor/materials on the installation, for something like 26 sq feet if my memory serves.

I don't know the brand on the material.  We just went to his shop and he gave us a couple samples of what he had available.

It didn't really have much of a stone / marbled look, it was more of a solid grey but I think it worked really really well with the rest of the interior design.

That is interesting - I am heading to a warehouse that has leftover slabs of granite and quartz tomorrow, they are certified and have great recommendations from someone who has used a couple pieces 6 years ago (still look great). We will see how the selection is. I also found several flooring & tile companies have a selection of popular samples they charge by the sq foot instead of by the slab, but it's still a markup over getting the slab yourself and prefabbing it. 

Post: Changing a carpet staircase to wood

John CollinsPosted
  • Investor
  • Tx, Ga
  • Posts 313
  • Votes 337

The wooden handrail is in good condition, just needs a paint job.

There are 15 steps, 10 of them are the same size and the bottom ones get slightly larger.

The tread is 66 sq ft, the risers are 37 sq feet and will be basic white. 

Getting engineered wood at $5.5 sq/foot with install to match downstairs. 

What should the final price with install be? My guy , who normally charges a good price on floors and makes up for it elsewhere, is quoting me at $2.5k. 


Steps will look like this (but with engineered wood tops not hardwood). 

Originally posted by @Cody L.:

I rent my house in Houston out for $4,300. And it’s not that great. 100 years old. About 2000 SF. Odd layout with only 1 full bath. 

But it’s in a nice hip trendy area. There are 1000s of $1m+ homes that rent for more

I bought the one across the street a few months back for $550k and rent it for $4,200. Not the magical 1% level but nearly 0 management cost given it's just another SFH for my team to take care of where they have plenty of other buildings. Returns about 12% CoC conservatively

Yes it would have to be montrose or somewhere trendy in the loop vs a gated mansion in the suburbs. But I'd be interested in the sustainability (vacancy, long term tenants) aspect of it compared to two $250k homes you could rent for $2.5k each not including $15-20k in renovations (each). 

Purchased a fixer upper myself at $490k (way below surrounding market) with $50k of work going in. Hoping to see a starting $4.2 k on it. 

Post: Quartz countertops to raise rental value?

John CollinsPosted
  • Investor
  • Tx, Ga
  • Posts 313
  • Votes 337
Originally posted by @Jim Goebel:

We have successfully used granite remnants to good effect for $300-$800 decent quality installs.

We have one 'quartzite' type of counters that are solid grey and look very nice!

My take is when thinking about these projects estimate the delta in what you'd get in monthly rent, by having the nicer upgrade available.  Then, compare that $delta to how much you'd pay.  If you can get 1.5 year or less payback for something like what you're talking about, then go for it!

So, if you can get nice counters for $3000, are you going to get an extra $167/mo in rent?  I guess its possible but realistically that is a lot of money to pay for something, and that's a generous assumption for increased rent simply tied to one feature.

It's part of an entire aesthetic that is raising the rent about $4-500 from what it was previously, but the house was outdated, not functioning the best and in need of major changes. It also allows the home to compete with pool homes in the area (pool homes are very popular amongst renters in Texas, but not everyone wants a pool and lots of people with kids specifically do not want them). 

Quartzite looks great - do you mind telling me what brand you found and at what price/sq ft including install?