@Anthony Newbold
Seems like you've already done your legwork, and you may laugh at my advice, but as emotional and stressed you are over this, if it was me, I would just hand it over to an eviction company and let them deal with this. I wouldn't let these criminals (they are stealing) ruin any more of my health or mood.
I had a tenant that literally ripped my entire house and stole everything... I think if it was a property that I was personally managing I would have been frustrated, stressed... etc, but honestly I wasn't so much.... my bank account hurt quite a bit and it put me back quite a bit..... but at the end of the day, I didn't have to deal with it... things like this discouraging investors from pressing on Or giving up on Investing I think is way more costly than the actual damage.
If this property is so frustrating to the point of you feeling like you wanna do something that will impact you for good, just cut your losses and let another person deal with them. At the end of the day, I believe God exists and they will pay for it at some point in their life. No reason trying to have them pay for it ourselves. And besides, you are investing with houses, these people are renting... they obviously are not doing well financially. Even if they make a lot, it's about how u manage them...... so just move on.... and know they will pay eventually.