@David Greiner sorry to hear that you are facing this battle. We had a similar fight in Columbus Ohio a year ago. I, and a few other hosts were successful in changing the opposition in Columbus towards being STR friendly. They were originally proposing a ban on non-owner occupied rentals, and a cap on only running one short term rental from your primary residence. After a year long battle, on July 30, 2018 Columbus city Council passed legislation that allows non-owner occupied permit holders to operate 365 days a year, and own and operate as many short term rentals as they want. It CAN be done!
I have networked with And worked with many other advocates for STR regulations in many other cities across the US at this point. The number one most successful tactic that we used and that I have seen used in other cities is to create a nonprofit organization of short term rental hosts. Include all hosts, not just investors or owner occupied hosts. Once that group is formed, then it is much easier to negotiate with the opposition. they will actually give you a seat at the table. It is also much easier to get support from Airbnb, Expedia/HOmeAway, and other interested parties.
I would be happy to connect you with the rep from Airbnb that covers our region, as well as other contacts that could be helpful in your battle. Feel free to shoot me a message.
Also, don’t listen to all of the “expert” naysayers above,(@Luke Carl) is just lucky that they work in vacation markets instead of urban markets where regulations are more of an issue. @Mark Miles, if you don't think anyone rents a STR house in Ohio in November, I would kindly like to point out that my business Airbnb payout in November alone was $118,836. Last 12 months in Ohio was $1.1m.