@Mark Graffagnino
@Mark Graffagnino were you intending to pay back that 50k or was that a withdrawal? I plan to borrow 30k against my 401k and pay it back with the cash flow of the property, thereby accelerating the payback to hopefully 3 years or so. Then, I'll repeat the process again and again, hopefully buying one rental duplex a year for the first 3-5 years. At that point, the rental income should begin to snowball and allow me to use the rental income to accumulate more than one a year, which is convenient because I should be more experienced at that point and know what I'm doing a little better.
Maximum projected rental income is 12k per duplex per year. I'm planning on pulling 5k net per year per duplex. That should allow for repairs and lost rent and other various expenses. From there it's simply a matter of buying enough duplexes and running them efficiently enough to develop a solid passive cash flow stream. In my area there's an abundance of 30k duplexes that will rent for 500/month. This is doable.
Now, compare that with keeping my money in the 401k. I'd have to continue working for YEARS to generate enough of a nest egg to retire and draw income on. I think that's what Mark is saying. I'm with him. He and I are both young enough that we can take a calculated risk where, if we've planned well enough, should allow us to retire by 50. And if not...we just keep working and we still have time to bounce back and recover from our mistake. Not to mention that real estate will still be able to be sold and allow at least 50% recovery of the funds used to buy in.
There's also the issue of the value of living ones dream. What price tag can you out on the thrill of being your own man and daring to step out on your own and embracing one of the greatest freedoms available to us as Americans: to own our own business and land without the tyranny of oppression. I'd happily earn less money and be my own boss! For me that DREAM is priceless. It's filled me with hope and energy as I've prepared to begin buying for the last few years.
There's also the issue of tax sheltering and savings by owning a business. There are significant savings available to business owners that aren't available to us as traditional employees. It's too much to list here, but it's easy to find using a simple google search.
I respect @Duncan Taylor for his wisdom on the number crunching. But I think there's more to it than the simple fact that you're just outpacing the S&P by a few percent each year. I'll be chasing my own dream, actively building my own personal cash flow business, planning for and hopefully retiring at 50, enjoying special tax breaks, stimulating my mind....and the list goes on and on.
It's a calculated risk. When done carefully the risk is quite low but the highly probable reward is great. If borrowing from your 401k won't sink you, then I say, KUDOS! Don't be foolish, but also don't be afraid to think outside the box and take life by the horns!