Hi Sam, yes he does own the property outright. I also thought the rental idea could work too but since my brother and I have become interested in real estate I thought there would be a better way to use the sale of his house to leave something for his grandchildren. Because right now, from what my mother has said, he plans on leaving each grandchild with something like $10k. My idea, and I don't know enough about 1031's to know if this is how it works, would be for him to find a multi-family unit or units somewhere, live in one, rent out the others and let my brother and I manage that aspect of it for him. But yes, maybe for now the best thing would be for me to convince him to rent the house rather than sell it. We all just think it would be a shame to let that beautiful house and piece of property go and not keep it in the family or at least turn it into something that creates cash flow for years to come and is something for my brother and I to start building our own portfolio of rental properties (not on Nantucket).