Hi Kevin,
Congratulations on the success you’ve experienced with your first property! Thought I'd put in my two cents. It sounds like you've set a solid foundation for your real estate journey. Regarding your options, both have their unique benefits, and your decision might come down to your personal goals and comfort with managing properties.
- Continuing to House Hack: Staying in your current home and purchasing another single family or duplex to rent out can be a great way to expand your portfolio while maintaining the comfortable cash flow you're accustomed to. Given the equity you've built and the cash reserves you have, this option might allow you to leverage better financing terms for the new property. You could also look into using a HELOC (Home Equity Line of Credit) on your current home to fund part of your next investment, thereby keeping your savings intact.
- Moving and Renting Out the Current Home: Transitioning into a duplex, living in one unit while renting the other, plus renting out your current house, can significantly accelerate your investment pace. This would shift your income sources and could potentially maximize your rental income. However, it involves more management and higher stakes with multiple properties. As for the current home, converting a bonus room into a real bedroom could enhance its rental appeal and value, depending on local demand for larger rental units.
Paying Off the Mortgage vs. Investing: Given the relatively low interest rate of 3.75% on your current home, and considering the income it generates exceeds the mortgage and expenses, it might be more beneficial to keep leveraging that property as is rather than rushing to pay it off. The extra cash flow could be used to cover any unexpected expenses in your new property or further invest in upgrades that increase rental yields.
Since you mentioned an interest in living in a new area, exploring out-of-state opportunities could align with both personal and investment goals. Just ensure you factor in the challenges of managing properties remotely or consider a reliable property management solution.
Ultimately, your choice should align with your long-term financial goals, risk tolerance, and lifestyle preferences. Diversifying your investment while maintaining manageable debt and cash flow seems like a promising strategy.
Best of luck with your next big move in real estate!
Warm regards,