@Josiah Halverson, I think it really is "black and white" a lot more than people want it to be! I realize there is lots of gray, but gray really should be the exception and not the rule.
I had a client who stunned me. Two months after he bought a home with an FHA loan I found out he wasn't living in it, and that he had never lived in it. I said "what about the owner occupancy requirement?" He said, "I intended to live in it, but I changed my mind. That rule is all about intentions, so I am fine." I was pretty dumbfounded, and haven't called him since. As an agent, I have no desire to sell him another house. The fact that this was a professedly religious person twisted my brain in knots even further. All hail King Justification! I will even go so far as to bring up the word "evil."
I have gone to lots of REIA meetings in 10 years of being in real estate and in many I learn some new "workaround." And in a vicious cycle, this simply impels the lawmakers to create a new batch of rules!
While I am not perfect, I really try to do the right thing by people and by the law. I challenge ALL BP members to regularly ask the question,"So what if I do 20% fewer deals because I refuse to exploit all the loopholes I know about????"
And then we need to say to ourselves, "I will be a person of integrity and do my best to treat people the way I want to be treated."
In "People of the Lie," the famous psychiatrist M. Scott Peck suggests that "Evil can be defined as a specific form of mental illness and should be subject to investigation like other major psychiatric disease." Wow! "Evil" as a legitimate psychiatric diagnostic category? Fascinating!
If people stopped trying to game the system, then the lawmakers wouldn't have to keep making it harder for us investors to make a buck. Don't you think it's about time to let those lawmakers go home and play with their kids?
It definitely seems that a potential $10k fine for blatant owner-occupant deception seems not to be a deterrent for some. I think this is clearly a sign of poorly developed risk-control brain centers. But I think we need to go far beyond mere "compliance out of fear." Let's all take it up a few more notches-- Take the high road. Do the right thing.