Originally posted by @Sachin Amin:
I live in Columbus OH, and have invested in in different states like TN , MS, MD, OH etc.. I actually like Tennessee and actually drove there to check out Memphis Turnkey properties, REI nation , Mid south home buyers and met all of them -(in waiting list since 1 and half year for Midsouth) - they all are great companies - I am invested with Memphis turnkey properties at the moment(2 properties). 50-75k range is now little tricky but yes you can get if you are lucky. what I am finding out with turkey's as I learn day to day - if a property is making $250 per door cashflow after (mortgage + escrows) that's $3000 income on that unit. However - when your lease expires or the tenant moves out after 12 months - the cost to get the property rent ready is avg $1 or 1.50$ per sqft (900 sqft unit) or something I provided in example below- so that is around $1000 to $1500 in rent ready expense. so literally I am only making $1500 on a unit in TN.
also I forgot to mention - add in couple of maintenance calls @ $100 each (labor+parts) which will eat up your income further down. so on the paper I made only $1200/year cash flow on one of the units. not trying to discourage but no one gave me this detail picture(dollar to dollar) when I started out. (REI nation, Memphis turnkey they all have fancy spreadsheets with proformas - but on the ground when rubber meets the road is little different)
if I had put in 50k-75k in S&P 500 ETF I would have made 30%+ return :) just kidding - different factors, parameters are in play here and pro's and con's on both sides :-)... but bottom line is Turnkey's are I would say still ok "ish" not great per my learning so far. Investor need to be little aggressive when it comes to demand bang for a buck - I am diversified in Stocks, real estates, 401k - all over - and all I care about is who is making me rich and creating wealth for me :-)
I started my journey couple of years ago to try out and I have learned a lot from BP community , youtube video's ,local meet ups podcasts..
Rent ready example :
$150 - carpet clean
$200 - cleaning
$100 - yard clean up
$400 - paint touch up
$150 - misc repairs - HVAC filters, batteries, door stops, etc.
Happy Investing!!!!!
I don't buy or sell turnkey rentals so have no dog in that fight. However, it is not comparing apples to apples when one only uses rental cash flow vs stock market gains, imo. The beauty of real estate is it has multiple avenues of return for the owner and all of those need to be accounted for when doing a comparative analysis.
The Total Return of rental real estate includes:
1. Cash flow
2. Forced appreciation
3. Market appreciation
4. Loan amortization
5. Forced Appreciation (turnkey providers generally provide some equity upfront is my understanding)
Some discount market appreciation in their return calculations as it's not realized until sold. However, their securities portfolio is calculated the same way. Market appreciation is an integral aspect of wealth building and shouldn't be downplayed, imo.
The Total Return of the SP500 (VOO) is its market appreciation. It has one avenue of wealth building
Assume you buy a $110k property for $100k on a 20yr note with 20% down that nets $120/month in cash flow and 3% market appreciation. The Total Return:
Cash Flow: $120/month
Loan Amortization: $235/month
Market Appreciation: $275/month
Total Return: $630/month or $7560/yr which is a 38% return, not considering the forced appreciation on purchase or tax benefits. The SP500 returned 15.76% last year in comparison.