@Ryan Karr
Let me begin by saying I am the President of Greater Cleveland REIA. I know all of the property managers.
I have sold literally hundreds of "turn key" properties and referred many of them.
I am good friends with many of them, have dinners and beers, heck we even buy and sell properties with them.
Now with that said.... THEY ALL SUCK!
Let me explain. They are not dishonest, they are not uneducated, but there is not a company on earth that will take care of running your property like you do.
To keep this short so it does not turn into a book instead of a post, you can choose whomever you would like and they are all about the same in price. Some companies will only work in certain areas, while others work all over NE Ohio.
Stay involved. Manage your Manager. This is YOUR asset. This is YOUR money. Pay attention to it.
Make sure you know what is going on and verify your data.
You would not let some dude in a white van take your kids to school, so don't turn over a massive investment to a complete stranger without keeping an eye on things.
I am sure I will get some shade thrown at me over this, but I am just speaking from over 2 decades of experience, not something a picked up at a weekend seminar.
Hope that helps. feel free to reach out to me if ya need help in the Cleveland market.