Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Mya Toohey

Mya Toohey has started 54 posts and replied 493 times.

Post: New Rental Property Purchase - Out of State

Mya TooheyPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Tampa Florida
  • Posts 587
  • Votes 280

I am also in Florida, the Tampa area. I can see why you want to invest out of state if that is your budget. Its hard to reach the 1% rule here now. If y0ou have a home at 300,000 you have to make 3k a month and finding a home at 300,000 and make that much rent is almost impossible. You can still make money on flips here though. What are your thoughts on doing a flip or a BRRRR that seams to be the best way to capitalize on your investment. I am not sure about the other markets but I would suggest looking up a Realtor from here and utilizing their knowledge to help you. you always need a good one no matter where you at if you are OOS investing. Best of Luck to you!!!

Post: STR in Bloomington, Indiana?

Mya TooheyPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Tampa Florida
  • Posts 587
  • Votes 280

I'm from Louisville KY and traveled to Bloomington for a Big Box company as a trainer. Due to the university there I worked with a lot of incoming families and getting what they needed for their dorms.  One of the biggest complaints was the lack of places to stay and the expense for such.  I'm sure how far Lake Monroe if from the University but I would also look into the amount of STRs in that as well.  

Post: The Importance of a Great Real Estate Agent: A Personal Paradigm Shift I

Mya TooheyPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Tampa Florida
  • Posts 587
  • Votes 280

So, I came from Louisville Ky down to Tampa Florida.  I thought I was a big fish in a little pond back home. What a drastic change when I came to Florida. We have the highest Realtor count per capita is the U.S. I had no idea what to do. I had already been in real estate for 5 years and thought I had seen it all.  One of the first deals I had (multi in an up and coming area) my buyer was paying cash and the deal was solid.  Back home I would make a packet for my appraiser and never had a bad appraisal due to the that I specified the value add and the Reno amount and broke it down so they saw the potential and it always worked.  So, I called the appraiser and explained that I would meet him on site to go over the paperwork.  The appraiser wouldn't even allow me to meet him which I had never had happen.  I'm very good at running comps and determining rehab costs. That's how I became so successful as an investor agent.  I called my broker and asked why??? He said it's standard practice that they don't want agents there. It's too distracting. As you can tell marine the appraisal came back 40k low and I was so dumbfounded.  I called my broker again and tried to dispute the comps the appraiser used. They me being almost two years old and more than 5 miles away. I presented unrefutable proof that I was right and my comps were solid and that they should change theirs and let the deal go through.  It got so bad that we even called the appraisal office to discuss.  They wouldn't budge. At that point we hired an independent appraiser and the numbers came back good and the hard money lender agreed to use them.  At that point the buyer was so Leary of the numbers they backed out, then the seller didn't want to give back escrow.  I mean really... I stayed on their "a@@" for weeks and pulled the we are getting a lawyer card.  I had to leverage my broker through the whole thing.  He was great and and had my back the whole time.  I got her money back of course, I learned that being the nice guy (which I am known for) has to protect their clients interest at all costs and you have to really use your head and figure out how to get it done while staying the nice guy.  The buyer was happy that I recovered her money in full that she wasn't even mad about losing the deal.  My broker said that most agents would have thrown in towel and not fight for what was the right thing to do.  So even though I lost a deal and commission I won loyalty and a client for life and became very valued as an agent and very successful by getting the money that was deserved and obviously, rightfully, morally and legally due to her.  

Post: A possible first STR property?

Mya TooheyPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Tampa Florida
  • Posts 587
  • Votes 280

@Tomoko Hale

With STRs its not just purchasing the property.  You have to set them up, market, book and clean.  You have to make sure that whatever company you choose will maximize your profits.  I would try and manage it yourself if you have the time and effort.  Then you get 100% minus cleaning fees and maintenance.  You really to examine your options with everything and be very choosy who you let run it for you!!!  I am in Florida and we have an influx of STRs and I did all that and taught my owners how to do it themselves so they didn't have to me the entire time.  Now some stayed with me and that was great but some learned that with a little bit of knowledge you can do it on your own.  

Post: STR hotel makeover

Mya TooheyPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Tampa Florida
  • Posts 587
  • Votes 280

Wow!!! What a cool spot!!!  I wish we had more spaces like that here in Florida.  If you can find one its Millions of dollars since those types of spaces ar3e close to beaches here.  What a great find!!!!  We use Hiscox for our insurance with our business, not sure if it works for property but its worth a try.  Best of Luck!!!!

Post: What Are The States With Great Real Estate Options To Move To?

Mya TooheyPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Tampa Florida
  • Posts 587
  • Votes 280

I have sold a few houses for newbies to househack.  It seams to be a great way to get startede.  The way to make money with that is to live in it for 1-2 years and then sell it for the equity and you can do it again and hopefully use the equity to buy two homes.  It all depends on the area and how much you spend on the rnovation.  I am in Tampa Florida and it has been very successful for my clients.

Post: Want to start my investing career but not sure what first step is best

Mya TooheyPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Tampa Florida
  • Posts 587
  • Votes 280

I am in the Tampa Florida area.  We have substantial job opportunities here.  Our market is also thriving.  You also don't have to pay state tax on income.  So, looking into this area could be smart for you all.  You also don't have to face those icy cold winters. LOL  

Post: What's Your Conversion Rate for Cold Calling Software-Generated Leads?

Mya TooheyPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Tampa Florida
  • Posts 587
  • Votes 280

@Mark G.

We tried cold calling and that didn't work too well...with Propstream you just use your search criteria and it will give you a list of prospects to reach out to.  Example: Absentee Owner-owned over 10 years-and the search area you are wanting to stick to.  It was really easy to navigate.

Post: Seeking Experienced Florida Real Estate Agent for Fix-and-Flip Projects 2025

Mya TooheyPosted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Tampa Florida
  • Posts 587
  • Votes 280

Hello!  I am in the Tampa area. I would be happy to help!!!  I have been doing this for 13 years and I specialize in it. 

I used Hostaway for my 9 units and it worked great. It m in the Tampa Florida area and it's very competitive.  It kept me booked at 85% which is great and made my life so much easier.