Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Richard C.

Richard C. has started 19 posts and replied 1919 times.

Post: Witholding Security Deposit - Smoke Damage

Richard C.Posted
  • Bedford, NH
  • Posts 2,011
  • Votes 1,614

Not a chance in hell would a court in my state let you take a penny for that.  The landlord at the time the carpet was replaced allowed smoking.  Smoke odor is therefore not wear-and-tear, or damage, but simply to be expected.

Originally posted by @Mike Cumbie:

@Richard C.

I am sorry you feel that evicting a non paying tenant is morally bankrupt. But I have seen nothing in any of these responses to suggest this problem is fixed and that the next rent will be where it is supposed to be. If it was over a total of a few hundred dollars I may act different, however in this case it looks like the housing authority is not responding and has decided to take the course of "Sorry we don't know you, best of luck to you, there is nothing we can do to help you today or in the future". 

The tenant is responsible for the rent period. Taking the "Not their fault" route is irrelevant, they are the one who have a case worker who can solve these problems, not you the landlord. If a tenant is "downsized" at work through no fault of their own, who is responsible for finding money for rent? They are. They are the ones who are required to ensure rent is paid. I do not care where they get the money as long as it is a legal source of income. S8 is a legal form of income for housing. When they go into the office with an eviction notice for failure to pay, someone will react (because it is their responsibility). 

How many months do you suggest the OP allow someone to live rent free while the old owner receives payment (or no one receives payment)? When a case worker calls the landlord they have steps to take and a process to follow. When a landlord calls the Housing office they have a voicemail system they can bounce around in forever. If you do not react in a timely manner then you set a precedent. Which means as you let this go on and on, the answer becomes "Well you let them send the check to Fred Smith for 4 months without doing anything, it is the way it is now"

I understand we may have a difference of opinion on how to handle it, however I am working from a place of in the best interest of the poster. Offering free rent until someone decides to take pity and answer a call in my opinion is not a solution that helps the OP.

Best of luck in your investing.

 That is not correct.  The OP stated that she has now completed the paperwork to receive future payments (granted, after 4 tries.)  This issue is SOLELY the one misdirected payment.

I stand by my characterization of your advice.

Let's review who has and who has not acted inappropriately:

1.  Your broker.  Appears to have done nothing wrong. Not great customer service to not return your call, but even if they did return your call, there is nothing they can do for you.  They are simply not involved;

2.  Seller's broker.  Almost the same situation as your broker.  They should be returning your call to tell you they have informed the seller, but they also have nothing to do with the Section 8 payment;

3.  The seller.  Clearly at fault if he knows he is not entitled to the payment and kept it anyway;

4.  The Housing Authority.  Sounds like the real villian in the story, to be honest.  If you filed the paperwork on time and they claim they did not receive it, then they are the ones who have put you in this situation.  And so I would really strongly recommend that you focus your efforts there rather than on the brokers.  The brokers have no responsibility here, the Housing Authority does; 

5.  The tenant.  The tenant has done absolutely, positively nothing wrong.  I find the advice above to threaten an entirely innocent renter with eviction, in the winter, to be completely morally bankrupt.  The moderator giving the advice may be correct that threatening eviction will get someone's attention.  But it may not be the attention you want.  And again, this tenant has done nothing wrong.  It is simply wrong to intentionally hurt an innocent third party because of your dispute with the Housing Authority.

Post: I have an ETHICAL DILEMMA!

Richard C.Posted
  • Bedford, NH
  • Posts 2,011
  • Votes 1,614

Well, if you do decide he has to go, just remember that if it is a 203k property, there is no reason for you to care about the condition of the unit. So refund any deposit immediately.

A 3 month fee for breaking a lease would never, ever be enforced in the courts in my state.  Things may very well be different there, but you should look into it.

Generally, you have a duty to mitigate your damages.  That means you have a duty to try to fill the unit, and if it takes you one month, then one month is what you are going to get, not three.

Post: 100% owner financing at 0% interest... is it possible??

Richard C.Posted
  • Bedford, NH
  • Posts 2,011
  • Votes 1,614
Originally posted by @Justin C.:

Well.. you didnt contribute in any way to my question, but I'll answer yours.  This is an estate.  There are 2 remaining children with families of their own.  By holding a note, instead of receiving and being taxed on a large chunk of money, they spread out this tax burden throughout the duration of the term.  Additionally, it creates an income stream for them and their families.  They also get to say they got an "amazing" sale price while sitting around Christmas dinner table.  

There are several reasons why someone would want to do this.

 This is almost certainly incorrect.

It is really, really important that you recognize that the estate is a legal entity entirely separate from the eventual heirs.

It is the ESTATE that would receive the money, which would then be distributed to the heirs.

The "tax burden" and "long-term income stream" arguments that people often deploy when seeking owner financing will very seldom (never say never, but very seldom) apply when dealing with an estate.

It is extremely likely that the executor is going to be trying to convert everything to cash, as expeditiously as possible, so that that cash can be distribute to the heirs.

I agree with the other posters:  any owner finance offer is very unlikely to be accepted by an estate.  And a zero interest offer that involves cutting a check to the buyer at closing?  Forget about it.  Unless the executor is drunk that day, or you have pictures of him in a compromising position, it ain't gunna happen.

Post: Do you look at their profile before considering their opinion?

Richard C.Posted
  • Bedford, NH
  • Posts 2,011
  • Votes 1,614

Nah, I virtually never look at profiles.  Usually only when they have sent me a colleague request.

I have been here long enough and read enough posts to have a good handle on who knows what.

Post: Do You Raise Rents Every Year? Why Or Why Not

Richard C.Posted
  • Bedford, NH
  • Posts 2,011
  • Votes 1,614

Rent is not determined by the amount you have invested, the CPI, any sort of rigid rule (I always add 3%!!!!) or anything of the like.

The rent you can get is based on the local rental market for like units.  PERIOD.

If you try to impose your will on the situation, and the market doesn't support it, you will pay the price.  Whether in vacancies, bad applicants who have no other choices, begrudging acceptance that results in pushback in other areas that costs you money, etc.

The landlord does not set the price, the MARKET does.

So, the answer is that you raise rent if the market indicates that you are underpriced.  

Post: 14 year old looking to build capital

Richard C.Posted
  • Bedford, NH
  • Posts 2,011
  • Votes 1,614

I think everyone needs to remember that this young man is asking for advice.  It is not a good idea to use that to rehash our own regrets in life, or to self-justify our choices by encouraging him to do the same things we did.  Not when the things we did have bad impacts far more often than good impacts.

I am specifically talking about the people arguing that this young man should not go to college (or even finish high school!!! WTF?)  

This may have worked out for you.  But if it did, you are very, very, very much the exception to the rule.  And the world of the future is going to be different from the world of the past, and it is unlikely to value education LESS.

Michael, the people telling you that you don't need to go to college (or even high school) are the exact same people who will tell you smoking is good for you, because their great uncle smoked a pack a day and lived to be 90.

Sure, it happens.  But as a real estate investor, you should be all about the numbers.  And what do the numbers tell us?

They tell us that the average wage of those with less than a high school diploma is $493 a week, with more than 8% unemployment.

That the average wage of those with a high school diploma is $678 a week, with 5% unemployment.  You think someone wanting to invest in real estate can find something to do with $185 extra dollars a wee?

The average wage for some college, but no degree is $738 a week.

For an associate's degree $798.

For a bachelor's degree $1,137 a week.

There is no, "But, but, but, he's an ENTREPRENEUR exception to any of the above.

People advising you to forgo education are giving you lousy advice, either to make themselves feel better about their own choices, or as a result of their own regrets.

It is LOUSY advice.  Don't listen to it.

Post: 14 year old looking to build capital

Richard C.Posted
  • Bedford, NH
  • Posts 2,011
  • Votes 1,614

I guarantee that there will still be real estate when you are 18.

Learn to walk before trying to run.