Quote from @Carlos Ptriawan:
There seems to be some confusion as to what the graph depicts. The green curve is the CPI-adjusted median price of a home. Various factors go into the peaks off of the average (speculation, supply/demand pressures, loan interest and inflation rates), but note that economically the pricing will need to revert to the norm at some point.
Thanks for the clarification, it's clear now. The problem with saying housing to revert to the norm as some pundits say is it doesn't reflect supply and demand, it doesn't reflect mortgage and it doesn't reflect the interest rate/inflation policy at a particular phase. Comparing 2010-2020 to 2020-2022 is plain wrong as inflation and interest rate are very different.
If a house has to go back to CPI status, we have to drop 50 percent which doesn't make sense unless there's a war, drop 10-25% seems doable.
In many Asian countries, inflation of 8% is normal sometimes. No gov is reacting for that. Only real estate is able to hedge against such a drop in currency or buying power that's creating inflation.
But this is good stuff, we will know which theory will be correct in short future :)
As you rightfully hint, it's really anyone's guess. But maybe we should think about other elements that go into this spike. Much of it was all the easy money chasing too few homes. OK -- so that bolstered pricing to the stratosphere. Who will now be able to buy the prices if they remain this elevated? If the average American is buying a house in the inflation-adjusted median value of $230k, what magically has happened to wages at the median level to allow for buying at $400k? Where is all this new income parity? It doesn't exist.
When a commodity is temporarily priced outside norms, and the support for that price increase (easy money) is temporary, what will happen to the commodity pricing? One doesn't have to have a science degree with years of advanced mathematics, or an economics hobby, or more than an 8th grade education. However, we have a marketing industry pretending to be real estate pundits selling the idea that this is a new normal and sustainable. All of us here on this forum have skin in the game -- and in our hearts, we know better. I do wish folks would not pretend this isn't a very dangerous bubble. :)