@Paul Choi Thanks! It was not the norm that's for sure, but as you said it happened out of much due diligence and strategy. Specifically 6 weeks of due diligence haha :)
Just as a disclaimer I am not a wholesaler by any means, but I do a very targeted yellow letter campaign that has worked great in my area for flips. Where I invest, I can only assume, is a completely different market than anywhere in California. So our numbers may differ because of that.
When I began my campaign, money and time was very limited. So I did the only realistic thing I could do, the minimum. List source requires a minimum of a $50 purchase and using the filters I used, it added up to about 300 addresses. Again, my target was extremely specific and I stuck to mailing 100 pieces a week pretty strategically. The material I purchased on Amazon and including postage it cost 54 cents/piece for my yellow letter campaign.
Before I was halfway through my first campaign I got my first deal, and since then I have bumped it up to about 300 per week. So including my $25 printer I had to buy, I was all in at $95. Which ended up yielding a 25k return. But here is a secret.. my call back % is almost 10X what most people's are. When I was sending 100 per week I would track my calls. Out of every 100 I would consistently hit 15-20 call backs every week. Some were just interested in finding out more information (Which can still lead to other leads) but most where actually in need of selling their home. This may seem somewhat unrealistic in some markets, but it is the product of knowing the market and being very strategic with my marketing investment.
My call back ratio has decreased somewhat, to about an 8% call back rate now. But I am sending more letters in less specific targets. Probate lists are something I am testing as we speak.
@Shawn Allen Moral of the story is if you don't have much money to work with, then obviously more time will be needed to bag a deal. And, if you're like me, you don't mind spending an hour a day to send out some letters at least to get your first few deals. Once you actually start making money, then I suggest you outsource so you can focus on growth. The key to any direct mail campaign is to understand that you HAVE to be consistent with it. And yes I completely agree with @Paul Choi You have to invest some money into it. But just be sure you're being intentional and not throwing noodles at the wall to see what sticks.
If either of you wanted any more info on my DM process I'd love to help in any way.
Good luck!