Originally posted by @Todd Willhoite:
You may be able to see a value add opportunity where you can change operations, or upgrade units, or cut expenses and get the Net Operating Income to increase more on one deal than another. As stated before, Cap rate tells you what happened in last 12 months, not what is going to happen in the future, or can happen if you have a plan. But without making any changes and if the properties will perform the same over the next 12 months as they performed over last 12 months, then in theory the 8 cap rate produces more than 5 cap.
Yes, I agree cap rate is always changing depending on a lot of factors such as tax rate increases, longer vacancy rate, or higher rent. But I think what most people refer to when talking about cap rate is can the 5% cap rate "report card" for the last 12months beat the 8% cap rate "report card". If we are truly considering the future value of a property, then I think using IRR is the better method than cap rate. So Ithe question is are just comparing report cards or are we comparing potential here.