Thanks @Jacob Wathen. Good advice. I know of a couple of wholesalers in the Eugene area but not as many as in some of these other markets so I'd love any referrals you might have.
To answer your question about my experience in the other cities, I lived in Nashville and still have family there so I feel very comfortable in that market. That said, prices have really climbed in recent years so I may have missed the boat on that one. I travel to Indianapolis regularly for work and have quite a few contacts there, so that's appealing in the sense that I could visit several times a year to check in on things. Michigan is the market I'm least familiar with, but I also have family there and some connections to some property managers in the area.
None of these areas are as comfortable for me as investing here at home where I'm much more familiar, but it's hard to argue with the cost of entry in some of these other cities. I want to be careful with not jumping in someplace too quickly, but I also don't want to sit here over-analyzing everything and never make a move.