@Meghan Begue
You had a really good question, is the higher cash flow worth the additional effort for STRs?
I’m sure you will get different answers from different people based on their expenses/revenues and their tolerance to hospitality work.
In my own personal experience, self-managing an STR can be quite a hassle at times, and not so bad at other times. 2 years ago my answer would have been that the juice is absolutely worth the squeeze for me. Today my position is a little more unclear. After recent significant increases in property taxes, homeowners insurance, utility costs, supply costs, maintenance costs, and construction costs the margins are thinner to a significant degree. There are still ways to make STRs work (good deal on a home, buying down to a lower interest rate, etc.) but make sure your profits are worth the hassle that you will encounter, because there WILL be some hassle with STRs.
If you do move forward, make sure you have some other exit strategies. I would not buy a house that works as a STR but not as a LTR. Also I would make sure to buy in a neighborhood with good or better appreciation potential, so that you are not only benefitting from the cash flow.
Hope this helps!