I wanted to say thank you to everyone that offered advice and to give an update on what I decided to do. I ended up calling Royal Legal Solutions (podcast guest #109 on asset protection). Scott Smith himself was not available but I spoke to his colleague, Kellie who has gone above and beyond to help me understand everything and to answer my questions.
They recommended setting up a Series LLC in Texas (where they are located) which will hold all the other properties. What I did not know, was even though the Series LLC is set up in Texas, I am still able to put other properties from other states within the Texas Series LLC. The properties that are in my own name are held in a land trust within the series LLC to prevent the due on sale clause and to give anonymity. The Series LLC is owned by my revocable living trust (which provides another level of anonymity). Even though this is still more complicated than I preferred from the beginning, I'm confident that my assets are protected this way. If I ever got sued, it would take a lot of digging for the lawyer to find out who I am and what I own. The price is reasonable at around $3000 and an additional $300 for every new property that I transfer into the series. The Series LLC also allows you to do 1 tax return for everything.
The other asset protection company that I spoke to (Anderson Advisers) wanted to charge me $5000 for the initial set up and wanted me to set up an LLC for every new property at a price of $1500 each, which I think is outrageous. Not to mention, they rushed me through the initial conversation and would not return my calls to answer my follow up questions.
I just wanted to put this information out there for anyone else who is confused. I think the price is worth it for peace of mind and protection.