@Zachary Jensen
Congrat’s on the first property! There are lots of great perspectives here so far. I fully agree that it is smart of landlords to treat great tenants as if they are worth their weight in gold. But, if this great tenant has been conditioned to accept annual 3-5% rent increases, why would you disrupt that, especially in a period of high inflation?
Also, perhaps consider hiring a good property manager to handle the interactions and everything with the tenant. I assume that and your wife likely would rather not spend your time working for close to minimum wage self managing. Especially if yall each have full-time jobs of your own already. Also, having a property manager may help to create some walls between you and the tenant who are already only separated from you by a wall. I’ve self managed and I’ve employed a property manager...I MUCH prefer employing a property manager. This is obviously heavily influenced by my personal situation however, and everyone is different. .