@Jon Q.
To your point about not selling houses unless it meets those criteria. I buy house that meet roughly the 1% rule. In my area they aren't everywhere, but they are out there and in good neighborhoods and come with quality tenants. This house at it's current value no longer would meet that rule with a refinanced loan. If we refinanced up to 180k we won't be anywhere close to $1800/month in rent. Which would now change my theory on buying the home if it was available today. So selling it to myself wouldn't make any sense, correct?
Using real numbers, I believe I can sell it and walk with 90k minus 7k in capital gains tax. I can use that 83K to purchase just shy of four $110,000 properties with 20% down on each property. Getting 1% return I would be receiving $4400/month in rent, have 4 appreciating homes, and still maintain 20% down on all of them.
If I refi up to 80% I can pull out $54,000 and avoid capital gains tax. With that I can purchase two $110,000 properties and have $10,000 left over to work on the third. I would still own the original home and be collecting $3500/month in rent.
Do these numbers seem logical based off using the numbers I know to be correct in my area for rents and home values?