I wonder if you had an idea of how long you wanted to keep the rental before you purchased it. In my opinion. If you had a "forever perspective" going into the deal, you'd be more selective of the rentals you buy. For example, kinda like what Warren Buffett says, his favorite holding period is forever. So, he's very careful to buy great stocks, not junk.
Something else to consider, the more variables you have in your business, the more complexity, and the harder it becomes to successfully identify problems and root causes to find real solutions. Case in point, investors chasing low-quality rentals to increase their door count, only to realize later mistakes when they're in too deep or hit major problems they should have avoided. Investors that keep having problems need to take a look at how much complexity they have.
And another thing, don't let everyone convince you into thinking you are wrong for paying off your rental. Taking on more and more debt and getting a bunch of doors increases complexity and can spread you thin. I hate how people are quick to assume everyone on BP only cares about getting more doors. It's ridiculous, people are out here with razor-thin cashflow and are living desperately from tenant to tenant. And what happens when COVID hits and you can't afford the debt service? The ones suffering the most are the new investors eager and unprepared.
Have you heard the saying quality is better than quantity? Or what about simplicity is better than complexity?
What sounds better to you... You have rentals in one state. In total you have 10 fully paid off A-class rentals cashflowing $20k per month. Everything set to run on autopilot with LLC ownership and a family trust for estate planning/inheritance purposes.
Or...
You have rentals if five different states. In total you have 30 maxed leveraged C-class rentals cashflowing $100 per door/$3k per month. There is lots of complexity with different team members living in different states. Maybe you transferred ownership into its own LLC too, against the due on sale clause because you never heard of anyone getting their note called.
What offers more freedom and peace of mind? What would be easier to hand off if you died? ...more complexity in probate court across different states/laws.... e.g. court appoints an executor in charge of liquidating everything to settle your debts and what's left for your family.
Let's not forget the average landlord owns three rental properties (30% of landlords own properties worth $400k or more, with 7% of the top landlords owning properties worth $1 million or more). Half of all the 'single-unit' landlords purchased their property initially as a primary residence (later transitioning it into a rental property). Landlords operating 2-to-50-unit buildings provide most of the affordable housing stock in the country. — Read all 29 Insightful Landlord Statistics (2022) here: https://getflex.com/blog/landlord-statistics