Break your thought process/review down into segments:
1. HOA- responsibilities.
- evaluate each responsibility. Example: do you have to pay $10,000 next year for a new road or sidewalk?
- How stable are the HOA fees at $xx? Are the units full or going into default, so you have to pick up more.
2. Need to do your financial analysis in more detail. Use one of the forum calculators.
- What are your revenue projections- assuming 12 months every year for ever, or using 90% rented?
- What are your expenses. Assume this is not a standalone unit. Basic expenses, NNN, capital expenses- replace carpet/shower/kitchen/roof/etc. Even if your not repairing immediately, you need to factor in annual set aside.
3. Built in 1960. Lead based paint, asbestos insulation or floor tiles, other issues.
4. Do a market analysis in the HOA and similar areas. Any new projects being built near by that will compete? Over the next 5 to 10 years, is this neighborhood improving or declining?
5. Start developing a checklist for future deal assessment. Incorporate the above and other concepts into it.
Straight up numbers look good, until you start replacing carpet, hot water heaters, bathrooms, etc.