@Joshua D. Prior to spending the money on other items at the property, be sure to confirm with the roofer if the integrity of the roof was compromised by any of the damage sustained. If insurance is covering the full replacement of the roof, or even partial, and you were considering replacement in the future... it would be best to move forward with the replacement at this time.
Insurance will pay Actual Cash Value (ACV) up front and withhold depreciation until the repairs have been completed. Depreciation is based upon age, condition, and useful life of the roof. For example, 15yr old roof with 20yr composition shingles may have up to 75% of the Replacement Cost Value (RCV) withheld until the repairs are completed. You would submit your receipts once the repairs are completed to recover the RCV. However, some policies are ACV only. So double check with your agent/adjuster.
There are two catches if choose not to have the repairs completed:
- You will not be able to recover the depreciation withheld.
- Without proof of repair/replacement, you may not be able to make a claim for the roofs in the future.
If you are able to have the repairs completed for under the ACV settlement, you will not have to return any additional funds. Just be sure to keep the receipts as proof of repair/replacement.
Hope this information is helpful. Let me know if you have any additional questions.