Originally posted by @Dustin D.:
Dustin, start making trips to areas that you might consider doing rentals in. If your market is over priced, there are plenty of areas to go to. Call people and talk to them about their area they are investing in. There are plenty of decent management companies out there that people here on bigger pockets are investing with. I recently went to Evansville, IN and met with a property manager/ owner who is investing and managing others investments for other people. Its a great fit for many, who enjoy the work. With 350-400k, you could have 10+ houses in Indiana, taking your 2100 in rent to 5-6k depending on some specifics. But even if its half of that you have spread out your risk and can change things up whenever you want. With a 400k home, it can be a little harder to sell due to price alone. I am not saying you should come to Indiana (please don't take that wrong). However I am saying that there is a lot more out there then the housing market you are looking at. I wish you best of luck and know that there will be plenty of people willing to help you. Just take your time, there will be some learning curve just don't give up!