Thanks for the response.
@Justin Owens I bought this property in Bargersville, which is south of Greenwood and is Center Grove Schools. The School system seems to be something people want and has kept rents up. I also bought it because of the location, it is by 2 parks, but has some land behind it that I might build a garage for the tenants (and maybe some storage for me). But not sure I want to do that when I can invest that money in to another property and probably get a better return. Did find out during closing that former owner bought the property for 119k 10 years earlier (not sure this helps). Also I am not sure what you mean by hold backs? After all of my monthly expenses (PITI), I cash flow about 500 a month. I have a small emergency fund for anything that goes wrong. But the furnace and water heaters are new or newer, roof is about 3-5 years old. I have had to take care of small things, but nothing big.
@Elizabeth Colegrove Thanks for your response. I new that I needed to do a deal and then analyze it after, to get me moving out of the analysis paralysis zone. As well as learning from my mistakes. My sole purpose at looking at this is to make sure I do better next time. Thank you.