@Neil Aggarwal, I'm looking in Greyson County because about 5 months ago, when I started really looking for properties, I saw a report of rental markets broken up by county. Greyson county was the nearest county that received a "green" rating (using a relative scale from red to green colors... would translate to a 1-5 rating with 5 being best, or green).
That piqued my interest at the time, but like you said, "surely there are deals close to me". And while that is true, I don't have a lot of time to spend looking into deals that are outside of the MLS. I got my license so that I could have MLS access and view/write contracts for properties on my own (again, a time saver).
In Greyson County Even with properties listed on the MLS in good-excellent condition, the list price to rent price is at or just above 1%. That is almost unheard of in areas withing a 45 minute driving distance. When there is a home with that ratio, its usually purchased with cash within a few days. I don't have that amount of cash to compete, and I also would rather leverage to gain the benefits of renter paid down mortgage and other tax benefits. Also the entire market is about 40% less expensive than what's around me.
Sherman / Denison Review
The area of Sherman reminded me of Denton, TX. A college town with most of the town consisting of older buildings, and the random factory scattered here or there. From my few hours in Sherman there seemed to be more noisy factories than in Denton, and larger areas of about 80-100 year old homes. The condition of these old homes seemed to be very scattered, single blocks having completely unlivable homes, to homes that have been remodeled one or more times through the years, all the way to much newer brick built with slab foundation. The East side of Hwy 75 seemed to be the "nicer" part of town, with larger homes in more "subdivision" type neighborhoods.
Denison seemed to be more "uniform" in its property conditions per block, at least for the areas I was looking at. This made it more "predictable" but also a little more boring of a town. I didn't see any areas that stood out a "nice" or "shady" areas. It was just sort of all the same, with the exception of a few busy roads where there was a large mixture of residential and converted commercial properties (buildings that were originally purposed for residential, but now zoned commercial).
I did by chance pass by one Commercial property that had a very well maintained and remodeled house with a separate converted garage. The Garage was a hair salon, and the house served as a Day Spa with massage therapy and sauna.
Of the properties I visited (about 12) I'm going to do more research and due diligence on 4. This includes the commercial property I mentioned above, A $150k ~2200 sqft home in the "nice" area of Sherman, an older home that's been remodeled to a great condition in Denison, and a new build in Denison.
Since it is so far away, I'm looking for minimal to no rehab on these properties. The ones that do need some work just need new flooring and possibly a painting of the kitchen cabinets. However after experiencing the drive, I'm nervous about following through, just because of the very limited time I have with a full time job, 3 young kids, and another baby on the way. I was definitely planning on using property management, but probably going to do that with local purchases as well. But the idea of having to deal with issues that a property manager may not handle well (or managing the property manager) is a bit intimidating for me with the homes being so far away. I'm thinking my risk tolerance may do better closer to home with a lower return. But I haven't quite decided yet. Still need to do further analysis on the 4 properties I mentioned.