Hey @Christian Podedworny
Those house prices are really low for what the rental market demands in your area!
I love using leverage to grow your portfolio. If you own that first place outright I'd absolutely recommend getting a cash out refinance and then use that money towards your next investment property. In fact, it might be worth it to you to get a HELOC on that investment (If you can find a lender who will do it) so that you can use that line and pay it back over and over again.
When you get into rental real estate in the right manner, the more property you own the bigger possible income you can create for yourself.
We've found that investing in multi family properties is a great way to increase the ROI even further. With an owner occupied FHA loan you can purchase up to a 4 unit residential property with just 3.5% down...
Or maybe you can use the cash you get from cashing out//getting a heloc to buy a multi... or both!
Hope this helps! Let me know if you have any more questions.
A