I would recommend checking out a DSCR loan for both properties.

Check out The Complete Guide to the Columbus, Ohio Real Estate Market which goes through the Columbus, Ohio market in depth and will give you a better scope of where the highest levels of growth are taking place and where to look to invest.

ref=shareMeetup group:Check out New England Real Estate Investors Unleashed https://meetu.ps/c/Dwmd/kYTB4/d on MeetupCome check it out, otherwise, I'd say your key these days is to have your all-in, be under 70% of after re paired value...

Your Insurance Agent may also be able to check it.  

For a great companion read, check out The Big Long, written by Waypoint founders Colin Wiel and Doug Brien.

Rental liquidity for a 4/2 is likely low, but I haven't checked.

Take some personal inventory first is my suggestion:1) Check your credit2) How much in designated capital 3) Out yourself in the proper head space. 

You're going to have skin in the game and lenders will look for it and check your DTI, credit history, employment history, bla bla if you buying in your name.

Check with a knowledgeable CPA about your tax exposure.Good Investing...

However, if you're looking to scale your portfolio or take a more hands-off approach, an STR manager might just be your new best friend, handling the complexities of running a hospitality business while you collect the checks each month.