I am trying to see if I should just try to find a cash buyer who wants to hold the property and I could either finish the work as part of the deal or offer it at a reduced price for them to finish...my other option is to try to do a cash-out refinance since we have done a significant amount of work, can I still get a semi accurate appraisal without the entire work being complete.

It’s illegal to sell a property with a loan on it3.

For those of you experienced in finding undervalued properties, what are the biggest risks and rewards you've encountered?

Sounds like your property is either being poorly marketed.Or you are overpriced and are letting your ownership bias blind you to that.

I recently had a total loss fire in one of my rental properties.

Alternatively, he could hire a handyman, etc. to finish up what he was responsible for and he can pay them directly.Alternatively, since you both own it, you could take on 100% of the management and your brother pays you X% of the rent like a property manager.

Quote from @Rodney West: New to mid term rentals and wondering if there is a way, or site to find out the demand by property type, bedrooms, location etc.  

We were buying and selling hundreds of properties from 2009 - 2015.

We are nearly finished renovating a rental property in Oklahoma, and have started rehabbing our primary home in Tucson, AZ.

My family owns and manages ~15 properties in Illinois.