Based on your goals, experience level, and my assumption that high earning w-2s tend to be demanding of your time, I actually think that there are better ways for you to offset your w-2 income.

West Palm Beach, Wellington, Palm Beach Gardens, Boca Raton, etc.?

Hi Jasmin, I host a meetup in Palm beach gardens at one of my properties once a month regarding Airbnb's in the WPB market, feel free to send me a message and I can send you the info. 

The point being - outside of being in a really bad part of town, our experience has been that appreciation will come to all who own real estate (in an up market).  

Sorry to hear about your experience!

Ill keep you posted on my experience with them.

Any one have any previous experience with this?

It is the equivalent of crashing your car then trying to buy insurance to fix the car after the fact.A home warranty or homeowners insurance policy will not pay for mold because mold is a maintenance issue.You didn't say what is wrong with the garage - if it's a broken door opener that is typically covered on a home warranty.My experience is mixed with home warranties and I can 100% tell you your satisfaction comes down to the local trade person that shows up.The home warranty company does not employ trades - they contract them locally at a fixed rate for the work performed sort of like how car mechanics are paid. 

Depending on the property type and terms this can be justifiable but usually reserved for those with ample experience and higher risk tolerance. - Higher and Hard Deposits.

In my experience as a landlord attorney and helping property management companies across Florida, the fees range from 8% - 15% (taking into account fees and commissions).