Obviously you wouldn't be able to get accurate market analysis to make comparisons, especially if the samples are completely fictitious, but some general reference points should be enough to make an educated decision on whether a deal is feasible or not. 

Does anyone know of a Qualified Demolition contractor who can help with permitting, Demolition and Framing?It would make sense for them to frame the house, they are already there and they have to support the structure...

I would also recommend that you factor in the following: NOI, ROI,  Cap Rate and Cash on Cash ReturnI would recommend that you download the Buy and Hold Evaluate Spreadsheet from BP files and then punch  in the numbers on all those properties so you can do a side by side comparison............remember this is the initial analysis based on pro forma which will most likely change once they have given you the actual.

You are the expert in comparison to them.

But that selection pales in comparison to the nearly 25,000foreclosures up for sale at auction in ten states, California, Florida, New Jersey, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Georgia, Illinois, Ohio, Arizona and Washington.It’s like Ebay for real estate investors… but it’s all real estate, all the time.

It's difficult to make a quantitative comparison, as there are so many variables involved.However- I'm editing the first post- I just found a site with estimates for heating costs according to the type of heat used.

By comparison many apartment complexes are going for a 6% return on investment... also referred to as a '6 cap' I can give you deals that I am turning down at 1.5% and you can get a property manager if you like. 

It is not apples to apples because different people have different ways they manage coming back but it will give you a comparison.  

Some may be ok with properties like this as the comparison would be that the fees cover roof, common grounds, exterior insurance but regardless, I look at it as eating away any kind of return.As others stated, you would do well to get the documents and P&L if you can to see just where the money is being spent and what they cover.Good Luck!

I will agree it may have not been the best comparison.