Justin Nero First off comparing the Bay Area to Indianapolis market is just not appropriate. They are way to different. The homes, the culture, the economy, the way of life ect. I have visited Indy and to answer your question you have to go out there and see things for yourself. Neighborhoods and streets that look great to me may not be acceptable for you. We all think differently. Generally speaking you could conclude that c class properties bring higher cash flow but higher risk compared to b class homes that may have less cash flow but are newer, and may have less maintenance, and may have a better tenant. For me I limit my risk in the c class properties by using the right people and picking the right homes. I also don't buy into the theory that b class homes have less repairs and better tenants. My opinion is that they can all go soar no matter what class the home is. I don't care what people classify a property as. Just as long as it is purchased, rehabbed, and managed appropriately it will be successful. That's my thoughts.
Now all that said I do diversify my portfolio with c class properties in Indy and B class properties in Birmingham. So maybe I do care a little bit about the classification. :). Hhehehe.