Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: William C.

William C. has started 29 posts and replied 562 times.

Post: Agent is “wholesaling” property on MLS

William C.Posted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Souderton, PA
  • Posts 591
  • Votes 414
Originally posted by @Mike Cumbie:

I may be missing something here (Wouldn't be the first time)

But to me it sounds like:

1) They won a bid for $150,000 that you and your client (or anyone else)  did not bid on. 

2) Before closing they threw it on the MLS for $225,000

3) You busted them on it and they have pulled the listing (Fair enough) and are going to require them to actually purchase it before listing. Which makes sense.

What follows is where I am confused.

Why does their sale with HUBZU have to stop and now end up going to you and your client for a number you prefer over their bid? Do we know if they can perform or are we guessing they do not have the money? Could it be a cash buyer won the bid and just figured they would assign it over if they got what they want, if not they would close? While I will fully agree that until it closed they should not be listing on the MLS, that hardly seems like cause to stop their sale and award your clients a price of their choosing. How do we know that they do not have another offer for 155K, 172K, 184K, 203K, 214K from someone who is willing to take the assignment or doubleclose it.

I know your guy wants to get it at a "steal" of a price and you guys are slamming them for listing it on the MLS before closing (which they should not have), But if this is an ethical fight over right and wrong shouldn't it be put back on the open market for everyone to take a stab at instead of just awarding your guy it for a great price?

 Your close, except you missed the part about the agent/buyer misrepresenting that why were in fact, the owner, and not a party under contract to purchase the property.  You may have also missed the breach of contract between buyer and seller when they gave access to us to view the property as an end buyer.  Or also when they breached the contract by either attempting to, or actually assigning the contract, which this seller explicitly forbids.

I see your point.  I may seem like a hot headed disgruntled agent that is upset we didn't win the original auction.  And that may all be true.  Fact is, they marketed the property, as their own.  Illegal.  When I called them on it, they lied even more.  When they were told by their broker they could not do such a thing, she still engages in negotiations on a property, she does not own.  All illegal.  And thankfully the real sellers agent agrees, and is cancelling the contract.  I will be the first to admit had they not ever relisted the property, my buyer would not have realized this thing was listed and sold....until they chose to market it as the rightful owners.  So my frustration and disgust is out the clear fraud and deceit by the agent/buyer.  Play by the rules, that's all I ask.  

And Yes I agree 100%, the seller should and will hopefully cancel the contract, and go to back up offers, or relist the property, and award it to the highest bidder, whether that be my buyer or not.  I will also be the first to admit my buyer does not have any right to the property at this point.   

Post: Agent is “wholesaling” property on MLS

William C.Posted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Souderton, PA
  • Posts 591
  • Votes 414
Originally posted by @Josh C.:

I get your upset, but perceptions change depending on which side of the transaction you are on. Had you been telling us you wholesaled in this exact manner and made 75k you’d be the BP hero of the week.

One of the podcasts was from a more experienced wholesaler saying he puts all of his on the MLS prior to him closing. If the agents can and do close and it's a deal at 225k I know it stings, but seems like they profited on an opportunity. Like we all try to do.

They didn’t lie to the bank saying it’s only worth 150 did they? The bank has brains. I’d take much more offense if the seller was a 85 year old widow like I see everyday. The uneducated sellers it what bothers me. Not big banks.

 I would never rip a seller off and collect $75k of their equity at the table, having done no improvements to a property.  I know for a fact homes sell for more money when more people know about them, not some "wholesalers" cash buyer list.  So your example falls on deaf ears.  I am the anti wholesaler, and anti cash buyer.  We offer sellers who need cash, a cash offer,  but we also offer them a partnership deal in the fix and flip, where they are the beneficiary when the home sells for 120% of market value.  I'm not out to make a quick buck, which is why I am able to sleep at night knowing I am doing the right thing. If they NEED to have the cash that day, no questions asked, so be it, we'll give them the cash.  We make ALL of their options clear to them, and make sure they know how each one will affect them. 

I would also not be in this thread has this buyer simply closed on the property, and THEN relisted it. End of story. They copy and pasted the banks pictures and MLS listing, word for word, 4 days after it went Pending. There is a right way, and a wrong way to do things. Just because others think ripping people off to steal $75k, and consider them the BP hero of the week, doesn't mean I have to agree with it. In fact Id argue BP needs to be held more accountable for the misinformation they allow. I understand its a forum, anyone can say anything. But on Podcasts where wholesalers are featured, they could probably do a better job of clarifying legal and illegal. It's not too hard to step back and ask yourself if what you are doing is fair to all parties involved. Wholesalers hate me, and they should. its clear by some of the responses. I love it to be honest. Just like late night infomercials of no money down investing have become American culture, I pledge to educate the entire world of the scam artists so they cease to exist. Lofty goals I admit. But I have a feeling as the Truth begins to spread, more and more outlets will be willing to listen to my story, and how people can avoid being taken advantage of.

If they have the sellers blessing to market, good for them, have at it champ. Not the case here.  Nor in a lot of cases. So your talking apples im talking oranges.  A quick search on BP will bring back countless results of "newbies" asking for ways to keep the sale price a secret to the seller in a wholesale deal.  That just makes me LOL, then want to puke.

Let me repeat myself.  By all means, PURCHASE a property, then remarket for a profit all you want.  But to lie about ownership, play games and refer to equitable interest, bring zero dollars to the table in a double close, act like it was a newbie mistake when you were licensed for 5 years.....All these fraudulent practices will be brought to the light.   

Post: Agent is “wholesaling” property on MLS

William C.Posted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Souderton, PA
  • Posts 591
  • Votes 414
Originally posted by @John Clark:

"What do I do? I NEED to stop their sale if it's still under contract."

-------------------------------

Now you know why I hold real estate agents in contempt.

 LOL.  okay dude. thanks for the input.  Agent or not, I expect people to act in good faith and be honest, and truthful.  Iv admitted Im biased.  Iv admitted Im emotional.  Iv admitted I could see the scammers ending up with the property in the end.   I have also admitted my buyer does not have the right to the property, I feel it should be relisted, or backup offers reviewed.  If my buyer loses, fair and square, so be it.   I have every right to try to stop what is wrong in this world, more specifically the industry I chose to work in.   

Thankfully it appears the actual listing agent representing the seller feels the right thing should be done as well, and is working to cancel the contract.  Evil does not always have to prevail.

Post: Agent is “wholesaling” property on MLS

William C.Posted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Souderton, PA
  • Posts 591
  • Votes 414

UPDATE: 

Real agent asked me to place back up offer.  She is working to have the contract cancelled, and will move to backup offers or relist the property.  

Still not out of the woods yet.  But is probably the best response I could have asked for.

Post: Agent is “wholesaling” property on MLS

William C.Posted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Souderton, PA
  • Posts 591
  • Votes 414
Originally posted by @Greg H.:

@William C.

To answer in order

-It appears you referred to me as a wholesaler which could not be further from the truth. I am just a guy that like Jay has be at this for decades and tries to be be pragmatic 

-Fraud and deceitful by the agent/buyer.  Probably/sure but that happens or can be interpreted every day in this business 

-My point was that you nor your client is the injured party therefore has no standard information to bring suit. Your client had no rights to the property. At the end of the day, they should have made sure they were the high bidder 

-Will they cancel?  I highly doubt it. Keep in mind “it ain’t personal “ to the Asset Manager and they all ready have an acceptable offer and a willing and able buyer as far as they are concerned. 

-If you buyer is still ready to pay $30k more and wants the property, why not make the offer to the agent and just “play the game”? I get the principle of it but at the end of the day standing on principle may not get the property 

I understand your point of view, and appreciate the input.  I am certainly biased in the situation, and can see how it may go both ways. 

I am not claiming my buyer had any right to the property.  Scammers need to be stopped, bottom line.  

I disagree agents are flat out lying about ownership on a daily basis.  There is no interpretation needed.  "Do they own it?"  "Yes."  That's pretty easy to interpret.   

We've made an offer, $30k more than they are paying.  They declined, as the have a "better offer in the table".  More lies and deceit.   Another attempt to drive up the sale price before they even own it. I refuse to allow my buyer to offer anymore at this point.  He is just giving them what they need, justification to close on the deal.  Otherwise they just cancel, come on lets not be naive, we know how this game is played.  

And now I have to walk a tight rope making sure I don't tip them off that I'm on to their scam, so that if they do succeed they will actually work with my buyer?  I mean, I've been successful so far.  They declined my offer as of late last night, well after her broker informed her she was breaking the law, and the fake listing was removed.   So trust me, I understand the 'game'.  Seems like a pretty unfair game in my opinion. 

So as she continues to negotiate on a property they do not own, you see nothing wrong here?

Post: Agent is “wholesaling” property on MLS

William C.Posted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Souderton, PA
  • Posts 591
  • Votes 414
Originally posted by @Brian Pulaski:

How did the selling agent (the one you contacted who claims to be the owner but is really just under contract to buy from Hubzu) have a lock box code and can give you access. Did you mention to the actual selling agent representing Hubzu/the bank that this person (their buyer) is giving access to view the property? If I was an agent, I had a house I was selling under contract and found out my buyer was holding their own showings (and not even present at them) I would be speaking to the owner and shutting this down immediately.

I have been part of deals that were shady and should have been shut down and resold to me for more... however I learned that this doesn't always happen and the seller will most likely sell it to the current buyer in light of what is going on.

The fake owner as I'll call her from now on, gave me the LB combo. Yes, shes giving out the sellers LB, and no, she was not present for the showing. Furthermore, she knew EXACTLY what she was doing wrong. I first called our centralized showing desk for the info and it was not in their system. Weird. The MLS read "contact agent directly". She knew it would set off a red flag if she had showing instructions in the system. Again, not a new agent making a 'mistake' This is a veteran scammer. So we spent 3 hours in the thing, my buyer has his contractors come back and go through. We run the numbers, blah blah blah. It wasn't until I got on the MLS when I discovered the scam....It's just flat out misrepresentation, Oh and it's also another breach of their contract with the bank.

I hear you regarding the sale. I fear the worst as well. I'll do my best to put up a stink, all the way to the real estate commission if that's what it comes to. I'm hoping that if fake agent has financial interest in the deal as a partner which her broker indicated, that I'll be able to use that to bring it to a stop. Otherwise the 'buyer' which is an LLC, can claim the fake selling agent was acting without their consent...which is obviously more lies, but would be tough to prove in court. And again, this will never end up in court, at least not from my buyers or my end.

The owner is a bank, if it were an actual person, I probably wouldn't even be on BP, Id be knocking on the door of their house and this would be an easy win for my buyer and I.  Might be hard to convince a bank to cancel the sale of a foreclosed property.  So I'm prepared for that outcome, and preparing my buyers as well.  I'm hoping the real listing agent does the right thing, acts in the real sellers best interest, acts in everyone's best interest, and cancels the contract.  Allowing them to win only perpetuates this scam.  I'm not even saying my buyer has to be the one to purchase the place.  The fake owners claim to have multiple offers, so put it back up for sale and let the market decide.  If we allow these scammers to get away with this stuff, they'll continue to do it.   There is only one way to put a stop to it, and that's put a stop to it.  I'm tempted be the first person to start running midnight infomercials. and facebook Ads telling everyone the truth about how these 'no money' down real estate gurus work.  I can't even logon to that site anymore without seeing 5 ads in my feed from the next guru with all the answers to  overnight real estate riches.  I am more passionate about putting all these scammers out of business than I am about actually selling homes.  I'll get off my soap box for now and keep everyone posted.  I am trying not to be overzealous and let the real listing agent get back to me.  I sent a 2 emails this weekend as the situation changed and new information came to light.   I am empathetic that she probably has 100 listings and this is the last thing she feels like dealing with.

Post: Agent is “wholesaling” property on MLS

William C.Posted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Souderton, PA
  • Posts 591
  • Votes 414

This is my last post for the night, hoping I wake up to some good news, and if not we'll just move onto the next one.  

Just shooting from the hip here, but if the "agent" is also a partner in the deal as confirmed by text messages and broker.  The state licensing commission will be compelled to step in.  It was mentioned earlier.  And as I ponder this is seems to make the most sense.  Why even have licensing requirements, if you are not going to enforce the rules.   Agents cannot lie about who owns a property, that's class number 1.  Oh I completely forgot to  call the broker out as a liar as well.  He blamed the mistake on her being a "new" agent.  I happened to look up her deal history when researching this debacle and she has sales in 2017 and 2018, albeit very few.  3 years licensed is hardly new in my book.  She knows exactly what scam she is running.

Iv had enough. Its my mission on earth to bring all scammers, liars, and fake wholesalers down.   As well as scum bag agents who are out for a quick buck. I am putting my flag in the sand today.  I actually put it in the sand last week after listening to a Gary Vee podcast about speaking the TRUTH, even when its not in our best SHORT term interest.  As an agent and investor, my truth is going to be to expose the scum.  I happen to think this is not a coincidence this is all playing out a week later like this.  Really wish I would have written a post about it then, would have been a lot more believable.   

Amazingly I started writing these "Truths" about real estate in my iphone in Notes....Looks like I can prove it, its dated Thursday, we discovered this property at lunch on Friday.  There is a reason this deal was brought into my life.  You all heard it hear first.

Post: Agent is “wholesaling” property on MLS

William C.Posted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Souderton, PA
  • Posts 591
  • Votes 414
Originally posted by @Greg H.:
Originally posted by @William C.:

@Lori Greene hoping I don’t need to go down the attorney route. I think once I bring light to the situation and the agent and the bank finds out what they are doing they’ll drop the agreement of sale. We’ll see.

 Why do you feel you can/should go the attorney route?  You are your client is hardly an "injured" party.  You have ZERO standing

 As a broker....what would you do in the sellers agents position?   Sweep it under the rug, or get your seller top dollar?

Post: Agent is “wholesaling” property on MLS

William C.Posted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Souderton, PA
  • Posts 591
  • Votes 414
Originally posted by @Greg H.:
Originally posted by @William C.:

@Lori Greene hoping I don’t need to go down the attorney route. I think once I bring light to the situation and the agent and the bank finds out what they are doing they’ll drop the agreement of sale. We’ll see.

 Why do you feel you can/should go the attorney route?  You are your client is hardly an "injured" party.  You have ZERO standing

Never said we were injured.  Never said we'd sue.  But deceived, yes.  My buyer can sue anyone for anything, doesn't mean he'll win.   Didn't I imply I wouldn't be going that route?  

Nevertheless they explicitly breached the contract the seller makes them sign.  At least in 2 ways, maybe even more.  The seller has every right to cancel and accept our offer for $30k more.  Why wouldn't they?

What about the message I have in writing saying they own the property?  Is that not considered fraud?   Deceit?  

If not fraud, then what?  

Trust me, I won't be getting an attorney involved, nor will my buyer.   He wants the property.  If your read the entire thread you'd see that I actually can see how this plays out in the scum bags favor.  But thanks for your input.  I have faith that when I speak with the sellers agent tomorrow she'll be happy to cancel their contract on 2 maybe 3 different breaches, and accept our backup offer.   

Post: Agent is “wholesaling” property on MLS

William C.Posted
  • Real Estate Agent
  • Souderton, PA
  • Posts 591
  • Votes 414
Originally posted by @Greg H.:

While this is against the MLS rules in all the Boards I have been a member of, it is doubtful this is a crime in your state or even a violation by the State RE Commission

While the seller may have a problem with it, they will not cancel the sale.  Most likely, an email to "stop" would be the stiffest penalty

 -Said the wholesaler