@Ann Bellamy @Ron S.
Ann, I believe the people I'm working with and Sean's friends are one in the same; they have been great through all this but I'm down to the wire and this decision is beyond them at this point.
Basically I'm deciding between
1. Keeping the house (#'s I outlined above or in previous post in more details)
300k mortgage, 210k value, 600$ out of pocket a month after rent collection even with 3% rent increase over the next 2 years and a 10% increase in value I'm still in a big hole; and I project 30 - 50k in repairs over the next 5 - 10 years.
2. Going ahead with the short sale
Paying 10K at closing, owing 21k in taxes (based on this years income + the deficiency (the deficiency amount bumps me to a new tax bracket to top it all off)
Hoping the MDRA get passed again this year (in which case I'll will be forgiven on the tax burden)
Hoping I can recover my credit score in a relatively short time frame; which is important to me but not the end all be all; there are other ways to finance deals as you both know.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Appreciate the feedback... I should have provided a bit more info....
I am in the thick of it.
My tax liability if I accept the offer currently in play is 21K, 17k federal and 4k State
I am bring 10K to the table for this deal
They are including a wavier on the deficiency but that does not help me in the Tax area
The MDRA was extended in 12/2014 for that year only; so unless they extend it in 2015 I will have to pay the additional 21K in taxes.
I ran the #'s on being insolvent and it doesn't work
I am current on my payments haven't missed or have a late payment.