Kim Herrick we just went through this. We bought our first MF which unfortunately included inherited tenants in Kansas City. We initially tried to get the sellers to vacate the units but they didn’t budge. We went through the deal anyways and did the following:
We closed beginning of January. We met with each of them and reviewed their contracts, making sure we were all on the same page. By week 2, if not paid, we gave them their X-day notice to pay or vacate. You’ll get a whole bunch of excuses but just point out the contract you covered with them and play it off as “following previous contract set in place”. Now, we also played the role as PM and not owners, which I’m glad we did as our bottom unit was very demanding in wanting to speak to the “owners” to try to get out of paying. We also offered a cash for keys for all units. Our top unit ended up doing the cash for keys and moved out by month end. Our middle unit paid up their late fees + rent and paid last month right on time now since they understand now that paying rent is a priority. Our bottom unit ended up vacating.
Overall, for being our first time handling bad tenants, I think we did ok. If anything I would of started the pay or evict paperwork from the get go, otherwise just stand your ground but be respectful. Good luck!