@Jeremy Pace All your advice is spot on and I agree with you. Your obviously versed with the system and are doing a great job. I am happy to hear there are some folks that are having a positive experience.
Its not a lease issue for entry, it's a Nevada Revised Statutes issue. They require an official posting of a 24 hour entry notice, so the handy man that has a scheduled appointment and a no show from the tenant then does have to leave and cannot enter unless its on fire or waters coming out from under the door. We are unable to call and leave a message to start entry notice as you stated in NV. Must be nice being able to in PA.
The rent abatement was not paid, ever, even after repair. It was past the 30 days. The inspections were only completed with a representative present. The handyman did in fact miss the switch plate cover and he should have replaced it. The point is the how the inspector handled it. He was promised the repair would be completed asap but was refused any concession.
This is another non lease issue. The basis for a constructive eviction in NV over property condition is subject to an opinion of a person in a black robe on a bench. Some Judges don't care what the law states or whats in the lease or how many time stamped photos you present, they do what they want in Justice court. Its their court. The chances are this would have been deemed, ordinary wear and tear and denied a eviction. It is a sad fact of the NV justice system. We have some really great judges that follow the law and lease and some that just won't. I could share war stories about legitimate move out charges waived by Judges that would fill a book, but I'll spare you.
You mentioned,"HCV tenants are hard to deal with, and HUD inspectors and counselors are hard to deal with". Why go through the trouble if you don't have to? Life too short.
Our clients make the ultimately make decision on their properties anyway. I just read the post to Donovan above. The difference may simply be that we don't handle C & D properties any more. Thank God. Its nice not having mace at the reception desk. Still haven't found a way to screen for bad personality either.
Peace