Jil - do not count on getting 10-15% return through a stock/bond/etf route. Real estate is definitely a way to go, you just need to figure out an exact strategy - in state, out of state, notes vs rentals, etc. You should definitely have a talk with an accountant. If you have IRA or can transfer money from your 401k, you may want to set up Solo 401k or 401k custodial account (Sterling Trust and Guidant Financial are pretty much your only choices as far as I know) - both are vehicles for investing your retirement funds in real estate without paying taxes on it while it is in the account. This route should immediately give you access to large equity you amassed in 401k with a much higher and stable return than the stock market, and you should be able to afford to look locally. The rental income does not have to stay in 401k and can be used for paying down the debt, and you would use the extra 50k for paying down debt as well. Highly recommend to shop around accountants and find one knowledgeable about this, put together a plan, find a local realtor, and jump right in!