Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Shiva Bhaskar

Shiva Bhaskar has started 53 posts and replied 506 times.

Post: Happy Thanksgiving (What are you thankful for this year?)

Shiva BhaskarPosted
  • Investor
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 523
  • Votes 475

Thankful for great family and friends, a growing (non- real estate) business with an amazing partner and clients, and the continued growth and success I experienced this year in my REI adventures. I am very much thankful to my amazing uncle/mentor, who guides me on this journey with the dozens of deals worth of acquisition experience he has, which have allowed him to build a portfolio worth tens of millions. I am also grateful for this community, and all the awesome, wonderful folks sharing their insights here. Thank you BP. Happy Thanksgiving all!

Post: Would you rent to someone who had a past eviction?

Shiva BhaskarPosted
  • Investor
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 523
  • Votes 475
Originally posted by @Nicole Obregon:

Is this a deal breaker for you? Is it an automatic disqualified? Or, do you take it on a case-by-case basis?

Here's some background info on my situation:

Renting out a townhouse in a decent, working-class area, some crime, but ok
Rent is $1,000/month, 2 bedroom, 1 bath, renovated

I have a prospective tenant who said that he has a past eviction, in 2015. His credit is spotty, but he said he's working with a credit correction / assistance company to get it straightened out and improved. He makes $5,200 verifiable income at his job. He explained that he and his roommate got evicted in 2015 because his roommate lost his job, and they had a hard time paying the rent. 

WWYD?

 I think it's commendable that you hear people and their situations out, and I believe in second chances, but no, I would not do this. The reality is that what he said might be 100% true, or not. You were not there. What you DO know is that this person got evicted. You can find tenants without evictions in C or D+ areas, as many other headaches as you may deal with. Why bring in someone who already has a bad track record?

This is your business, the product of your hard work and focus. This is an asset for you and your family. It's something to be proud of. You cannot let someone who may damage it, become a part of the situation. Rules are rules. Evictions and violent crime convictions are an absolute no for me. 

Post: Why hasn't the market crashed yet?

Shiva BhaskarPosted
  • Investor
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 523
  • Votes 475
Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:
Originally posted by @Shiva Bhaskar:

I think the market is softer than it was a year ago - stuff is sitting around for longer, and there are more places being sold for reduced prices. Who knows what a few more rate hikes will do, not to mention, the reality that we have gone a record time (or close to it) without a recession? Granted, the 2007-09 downturn was really bad, so crawling out of that hole took longer, so that may be why this cycle has gone for longer. 

The thing is, unless you are an experienced investor, or have at least done several deals and have some relationships, I think assuming that you'll be able to pile in and buy during a major slowdown is not a great idea. The people doing deals earlier in the cycle, or in the market for a long time, are more likely to get their hands on those opportunities, than someone who is not known.  I think even in 2008 to 2011, when we were at the trough, most of the folks who grabbed great deals had prior experience. So, figuring out what you are looking for, and doing good deals based on it, makes more sense than waiting around IMHO. 

in those days is was cash buyers..  credit froze like a rock there for 2 to 3 years.. and only the top 1% ers were getting financing.

those I knew were borrowing against their stocks and bonds to buy deals at 1 over libor.. the rich got richer.. :)  average person could not get a investor loan to save their life.. banks went into lock jaw mode and that's one of the reasons the market CRASHED... 

even if rates go up that will create a slow down no doubt.. but not a crash.. its lack of financing altogether that created the crash.. along with all the crappy loans that were written. pre 07  

 Very true. Know a guy who, with his dad, bought 5 or 6 courthouse auction single family properties, in a 6 month span, in southern California. This was in 2009. All of these were homes in the Inland Empire, built between 1990 to 2000, or later, so very little deferred maintenance. 

Kept them rented and cash flowing throughout the slow times, and they are worth probably 3x what they paid, if not closer to 4x. Think they refinanced out to buy elsewhere :-) Cap rates are insane if you look at what they got these for (I think around $40K to $60K each), and they rent for like $1400 to $1700 today. Can't imagine an opportunity like that again. 

Post: Why hasn't the market crashed yet?

Shiva BhaskarPosted
  • Investor
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 523
  • Votes 475

I think the market is softer than it was a year ago - stuff is sitting around for longer, and there are more places being sold for reduced prices. Who knows what a few more rate hikes will do, not to mention, the reality that we have gone a record time (or close to it) without a recession? Granted, the 2007-09 downturn was really bad, so crawling out of that hole took longer, so that may be why this cycle has gone for longer. 

The thing is, unless you are an experienced investor, or have at least done several deals and have some relationships, I think assuming that you'll be able to pile in and buy during a major slowdown is not a great idea. The people doing deals earlier in the cycle, or in the market for a long time, are more likely to get their hands on those opportunities, than someone who is not known.  I think even in 2008 to 2011, when we were at the trough, most of the folks who grabbed great deals had prior experience. So, figuring out what you are looking for, and doing good deals based on it, makes more sense than waiting around IMHO. 

Post: Holiday gift for tenants

Shiva BhaskarPosted
  • Investor
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 523
  • Votes 475

It's interesting, when I lived in New York City, I remember hearing of folks who lived in nice, relatively higher paying apartment complexes receiving small gifts for renewing their lease. The management would also do what Paul mentioned, hosting events for residents for holidays etc. Of course, people were paying $3000 plus for a one bedroom in most of these places, sometimes closer to $4,0000. I think if you have a tenant who has paid on time, and not been a hassle, a gift is a nice gesture. An even cheaper gesture, is if you know their birthday (from the rental application), sending an email or text wishing them well on that date as well.

I have a rental where the tenants have only been there since August but always pay timely, keep the area clean, give me mail sent to the property for me, and signed a long-term lease with us - I'l give them a Starbucks card (we have one walking distance from the property), and a nice note thanking  them for being good tenants. This is a house that rents for $3,000 per month. Would I do it if they were paying $600 and it was not in a great area? Honestly, less likely to do so. I think you may as well give them something, if they've been good. 

Post: For those focused on BRRRR...

Shiva BhaskarPosted
  • Investor
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 523
  • Votes 475
Originally posted by @Mike Dorneman:
@Courtney M. I’ve got 3 young daughters and I try to involve them as much as I can in our real estate business. Here’s why I’m telling you this. When I go to view properties I often bring the kids. They’ve gotten to the point that when we walk into a perspective property and It’s disgusting and stinks, I asl them what they think. Their response, “Smells like money Dad!!” So, I’ve found success with making cash offers on homes that primarily require cosmetic fixes. I’m buying these anywhere from 20-50% below market value. We renovate, rent and refi our cash back out usually within 6 weeks. Find the next property, and do it all over again. We started about 1.5 years ago and we’re (my wife and I) currently working on #11. Let me know if you have any questions regarding the specifics of BRRRing Best of luck!!

 I love this! Your daughters are correct! 

Post: Interested in a meetup for South Bay investors?

Shiva BhaskarPosted
  • Investor
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 523
  • Votes 475

Hi all, sorry for the delay! I am going to look into a few venues in the South Bay, and see if we can do this in November. If anyone has suggestions, please direct message me.

Post: 68 Unit Case Study- First Multifamily Property

Shiva BhaskarPosted
  • Investor
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 523
  • Votes 475

Originally posted by @Eddie Delaney:

I wanted to share my story...it's stories like this that kept me motivated and I hope it can do the same for those on the sidelines or those getting started.

It's been 7 months and we are about nearly finished with the rehab to our first multifamily complex we picked up in April. For those who didn't read or remember my last post, let me give you a little background. I am a contractor that has worked for other investors rehabbing their apartments. After about 15 years of talking myself out of it, my brother and I finally committed to investing in our own multifamily property.  Most of our money was tied up in a vacation home in Nosara, Costa Rica ( we love to surf).  We had a blast and my kids loved it too, but there wasn't much financial return besides appreciation...time to sell! We had nearly 900K in equity. Fortunately it sold quickly and we were looking to put it to use.  We closed in February '18.  Didn't take long before we found out one of our customers was in a squeeze. Three of his properties in Orange, TX flooded during Harvey and he only had insurance on one of them. He sold me that property for 1.1 million. Closed in April '18 , the timing was perfect. But the purchase left us cash strapped. Fortunately, we did have another large project going that helped us out...(rehab of 138 units that flooded in Spring, TX) Every ounce of profit we had was dumped into our property. That got us through all the basic rebuild until we secured a 750K loan to finish.  So this is the breakdown.  

1.1 purchase price 

1 million invested in the rehab.

Proforma rents $51K/ month  (65% occupied today and expect to 95-100 by January.)

Stabilized Value $3.5 ? 

We ended up putting a great product together for the community. Leasing agent is filling it up nicely. New cabinets/ Granite/ LVT flooring and SS appliances. Changed out the siding and new paint.  Some might argue we over spent, but I'm hoping that we will have less turnover and hopefully less maintenance.

So what's next? Don't know. I'm considering going to FL...but can't refinance until March or May.  Open to partnering or hear of best strategy from here. Sell or refi?  

 Awesome work Eddie! Huge fan of Costa Rica myself - bet it was hard to let go of that house but this is great. Awesome what you are doing for your community with this. I know things have been rough after floods.

These are really nice finishes - I tend to agree with your strategy of reducing turnover by offering something higher quality. Have a rental in a B area here in LA that we redid floors, bathroom, added nice value to the property (at least 2x what we spent) and got a great tenant on a 3 year lease, and over 15% higher rent than before. I don't think it would have happened with the finishes we had before. 

Seems like a refi would be better here unless you have a deal you can 1031 this for? Just feels like this is a solid asset, so not worth letting go unless something much better comes along. Congrats again and thanks for sharing! 

Post: Do any of you play the lottery?

Shiva BhaskarPosted
  • Investor
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 523
  • Votes 475

Did play fantasy football, and with my luck, player selections and injuries the past year or two, I might as well be playing the lottery - luck hasn't been much better!

Post: Thoughts on Cleveland REI after a 4+ day investor visit

Shiva BhaskarPosted
  • Investor
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Posts 523
  • Votes 475
Originally posted by @Nate Zeigler:

I've lived in the greater Cleveland area my entire life and @shiva Bhaskar has a reasonable assessment. However, the areas he references, Tremont and Ohio city have done well, they may be tapped out.

There are many different unique markets within cuyahoga county and the northeast ohio area. I'm just getting into real estate investing and have been surprised to see some of the out of state investors buying in terrible areas in Cleveland. I guess it depends what you are looking for, but if you are from an area like San Francisco, LA or any larger market, I suspect the Cleveland area may operate differently than you are used to. 

Cleveland is a great place to live and invest - with caution. There are certain areas which will not appreciate in the near-term, and other areas with low crime and good schools that will still only see minimal appreciation. I would highly recommending visiting and/or partnering with someone local.

 I agree re Ohio City and Tremont actually. I think for a lot of out of state investors, cash flow in decent areas is strong, so appreciation is icing on the cake. I plan on partnering with some of the local folks we've gotten to know when the right opportunity presents itself.