Hi Scott,
I allow pets in all five of my rentals (in VA and TX) and have had no problems. I attribute this to:
- Type of property (all are class A rentals in great locations that appeal to responsible, professional tenants)
- Rigorous pre-screening of pet and owner. A good, responsible owner who has committed to training their dog and ensuring it has proper manners, is much, much more important than the breed for me, so I don't discriminate based on type or size. I will say that it is important to watch the interaction between pet and owner when you meet them, as this will give you insights into whether the owner has spent time properly training their pet (mostly applicable to dogs, as that is what all my rentals have currently).
- Do check with your insurance company as Michele mentioned, however, as they may have some restrictions on certain breeds and you don't want to find out you are not covered if something occurs.
- Refundable pet deposit. This provides an incentive for tenants to take care of the unit. I don't charge monthly pet rent, generally, as my tenants are paying towards the top end of the price range for my units, and it generally isn't too common in my area. Listen to the other investors in your area as they can let you know what tenants are typically paying in terms of monthly pet rent or deposits, so you are in line with what others are offering in the rental marketplace.
- Generally, I think the only common pet I would be opposed to a tenant having would be a puppy. As cute as they are, even the most responsible pet owner cannot prevent occasional (or multiple!) messes on the floor and/or puppy escape artists chewing or destroying items when their backs are turned for a second. Luckily, all of my tenants have had well-trained, indoor pets that had already lived through their puppy years in someone else's property.
Finally, I'll just echo that renting to responsible people with pets is beneficial in that they really do stay longer and reduce turnover costs. The first family with two Bassett Hounds that I rented my first sfr to is still there 4 years after I purchased the property. They even asked to install a dog door at their expense, which I of course, approved. And they just signed another 2 year lease. :)
Good luck and let us know how it goes!