Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Ryan Spearman

Ryan Spearman has started 17 posts and replied 79 times.

Post: Michael Blank Mentoring?

Ryan SpearmanPosted
  • Auckland, New Zealand
  • Posts 80
  • Votes 36

How is this course going now. 

I’m very curious about the multi-family courses, but it’s hard to get a proper idea of how they all work

Post: Where should I buy a multi-family for $1.6M?

Ryan SpearmanPosted
  • Auckland, New Zealand
  • Posts 80
  • Votes 36
Quote from @Sara Frank:
Quote from @Ryan Spearman:

Hi, 

I am a property investor in New Zealand with a portfolio of mainly small multi-families.

I will be selling off some of my individual units in about a year's time which should give me approx US$640k. 

As I have learned essentially all my property investing knowledge from the BiggerPockets podcast I can't help but come back to the idea of multi-family investing in the US. We don't have anything like that asset class here in NZ, 12 units are about as large as you can get. Even that is uncommon.

I've spoken to lenders in the states and I can only borrow 60% as a foreign investor. This gives me about $1.6 million to play with.

I have no ties to any particular state and a year to do my research. I imagine I can narrow it down to an amazing deal within that time.

Where should I buy? How big?

I'm looking for a classic value add, well cash-flowing property, that I can eventually refinance out a decent chunk of my capital while retaining a sizable cash flow.

Any and all advice would be welcome. I need to find a full team over there that I can lean on. I'm really hoping to develop long-lasting professional relationships in order to establish myself as an international property investor.

Thanks in advance

Ryan


 Being out of country the biggest question you want to ask yourself is how much work you want to put into land lording. There are pros and cons to the two schools of thought: higher risk lower price assets in middle states VS low risk higher priced assets on the coasts. A third option if youre looking for true passive income could be to invest in a syndication  

 Thanks @Sara Frank. That’s definitely a major part of my research. 
I need enough cashflow to make it worth my while, while at the same time making it smooth enough to run nicely. 
It all comes back to finding a great team to manage the property well and performing a great reno at the front end to bring down maintenance throughout the first years of the assets life. 
I must admit, despite already investing out of my city, the idea of investing out of the country is pretty daunting 

Post: Where should I buy a multi-family for $1.6M?

Ryan SpearmanPosted
  • Auckland, New Zealand
  • Posts 80
  • Votes 36
Quote from @Jared Prevost:

Hi @Ryan Spearman

Looks like you've got a lot of good info here, if you haven't noticed, every investor will happily point out the best parts of their particular market (it's this weird 'My market is the best market' mentality investors seems to have')

Where should I buy?

You need to establish some goals or criteria before answering this question, you can make money in every market in the US. Here are some questions I'd be asking myself:

-  At the commercial multifamily level, everything SHOULD cash flow if underwritten correctly. What's more important to you, cash flow or appreciation? There is a natural tradeoff here

- Do I want to asset to be in a city or area I'd like to visit? Or do I not care personally about the location?

- Do I want to invest in a competitive market (going to be more work to find a deal) or invest in 'overlooked' markets where brokers, sellers, and agents will give me more attention?

How Big?

If you can buy up to $1.6M purchase price and renovation and want to buy a single asset, you're looking at the 8 - 26 unit range depending on the market and how distressed the asset is. I would recommend buying a single asset as you can scale operations easier and devote attention to one building.

Finding a Team

I'm going to be honest with you here, the odds of you messing up your first multifamily deal while investing from abroad is much higher than a local investing in multifamily who has done a few deals already in that market.

I would recommend finding some syndication groups you like who buy smaller deals and coming in as a $50k or $100k limited partner so you can observe and learn. Then, when you start looking for your own deals to run, you can general partner with the syndication group you've gotten to know and they can help you run the deal successfully.

Thanks Jared. The team is definitely the key, and absolutely where I want to devote most of my time 

Post: Jake and Gino Mentorship

Ryan SpearmanPosted
  • Auckland, New Zealand
  • Posts 80
  • Votes 36

How did it go for you with these guys? 
Did you end up joining?

I’d love to know more about them too

Post: Where should I buy a multi-family for $1.6M?

Ryan SpearmanPosted
  • Auckland, New Zealand
  • Posts 80
  • Votes 36
Quote from @Justin Rademacher:

Minnesota is a fantastic option for what you are looking to do. My partners and I have 25 unit apartment complex we own in Rochester MN. The nice part about MN is that there is a perfect opportunity to cashflow...create some value with value add potential...and then cash out when complete. This is our current strategy with the 25 unit. 

The market obviously is different from city to city but while you do your research I would look into the following:

Saint Cloud MN, Minneapolis/Saint Paul MN, and Rochester MN

Sounds perfect. What’s the purchase price on a 25 unit there?

Post: Where should I buy a multi-family for $1.6M?

Ryan SpearmanPosted
  • Auckland, New Zealand
  • Posts 80
  • Votes 36
Quote from @Hadar Orkibi:

I want to insert comments on a few of the above statements. 

1. Saying that "Rustbelt has no upside" is nonsense; I have many friends that invest in the "Rustbelt," and all of their deals have an upside and force appreciation. Note: some parts of the Rust Belt are areas that, In my opinion, are not Landlord friendly enough and have a high cost of living. So not my first choice to invest in. 

2. @Ryan Spearman Yes, that's why I started investing in USA Multifamily 5 years ago. No cash flow in NZ unless you are buying Commercial Real Estate NNN with a higher yield. New Zealand is a tough place to invest because borrowing money is VERY DIFFICULT, and you don't get a Big Banng for your Buck.

3. 10% Net Cap is something that you need to understand. In the US @Ryan Spearman we are calculating returns differently. Especially with Multifamily, which is based on NOI. Up t about 4 Months ago, Yes, it was easy to Cashflow with 100% financing. I did two cashout refinancing over one property in the last two years, and even after pulling few hundred thousand out, the property cash flowed pretty much the same. We call it the refi and role strategy or the BRRRR.

3. A: Now that rates are 7%-8% (and going higher) High, double-digit Cashflow is harder to achieve within the first year until the property is fully stabilized. 

3:B: 100% financing is Not a strategy for beginners in a correcting, volatile, trading downward market. Or with negative sentiment. 

I hope that helps!

Thanks Hadar, lots of important information there. 
I only ask about 100% financing as I now treat any investment I take on as being 100% finance. Generally any excess cash I have is a result of refinancing or at the very least could be used to pay down debt, therefore it is part of the finance of the deal 

Post: Where should I buy a multi-family for $1.6M?

Ryan SpearmanPosted
  • Auckland, New Zealand
  • Posts 80
  • Votes 36
Quote from @Bob Stevens:
Quote from @Jon A.:
Quote from @Ryan Spearman:

Hi, 

I am a property investor in New Zealand with a portfolio of mainly small multi-families.

I will be selling off some of my individual units in about a year's time which should give me approx US$640k. 

As I have learned essentially all my property investing knowledge from the BiggerPockets podcast I can't help but come back to the idea of multi-family investing in the US. We don't have anything like that asset class here in NZ, 12 units are about as large as you can get. Even that is uncommon.

I've spoken to lenders in the states and I can only borrow 60% as a foreign investor. This gives me about $1.6 million to play with.

I have no ties to any particular state and a year to do my research. I imagine I can narrow it down to an amazing deal within that time.

Where should I buy? How big?

I'm looking for a classic value add, well cash-flowing property, that I can eventually refinance out a decent chunk of my capital while retaining a sizable cash flow.

Any and all advice would be welcome. I need to find a full team over there that I can lean on. I'm really hoping to develop long-lasting professional relationships in order to establish myself as an international property investor.

Thanks in advance

Ryan


 I can't imagine managing an apartment building from such a distance without having substantial infrastructure (i.e. lots of employees, maybe a local office). You might consider commercial properties where the landlord generally has fewer responsibility. A triple net lease.
In terms of locale, one thing I've not read about in the comments is climate change. I would not recommend buying near water or in the vicinity of a flood zone. If looking at the sunbelt, consider that those areas will have serious water shortage issues in the coming decades. Probably only the largest cities will have the capital and tax base to address that issue. And, as usual, probably only the wealthiest neighborhoods in those larger city will actually get assistance from the government.


 I know dozens and dozens of investors from overseas that have never even been to the city where their house is and are not involved with anything, Team handles all. Heck I only go to Cleveland twice a year, during the warm months all is handled for me. 

Agree. Leverage comes in way more forms than just financial. 
Most of the cities and towns I invest in in NZ I would go to less than once a year. 
Any decision I need to make as the owner can be done via email. If it’s a real disaster I might actually have to talk to someone on the phone

Post: Where should I buy a multi-family for $1.6M?

Ryan SpearmanPosted
  • Auckland, New Zealand
  • Posts 80
  • Votes 36
Quote from @Bob Stevens:
Quote from @Jack Seiden:
Quote from @Stephanie P.:
Quote from @Jack Seiden:
Quote from @Ryan Spearman:

Hi, 

I am a property investor in New Zealand with a portfolio of mainly small multi-families.

I will be selling off some of my individual units in about a year's time which should give me approx US$640k. 

As I have learned essentially all my property investing knowledge from the BiggerPockets podcast I can't help but come back to the idea of multi-family investing in the US. We don't have anything like that asset class here in NZ, 12 units are about as large as you can get. Even that is uncommon.

I've spoken to lenders in the states and I can only borrow 60% as a foreign investor. This gives me about $1.6 million to play with.

I have no ties to any particular state and a year to do my research. I imagine I can narrow it down to an amazing deal within that time.

Where should I buy? How big?

I'm looking for a classic value add, well cash-flowing property, that I can eventually refinance out a decent chunk of my capital while retaining a sizable cash flow.

Any and all advice would be welcome. I need to find a full team over there that I can lean on. I'm really hoping to develop long-lasting professional relationships in order to establish myself as an international property investor.

Thanks in advance

Ryan

It really depends on your goals, if you are looking for more cash flow and slightly more elevated risk, go for markets like Baltimore,Pittsburgh and other Midwest/rust belt cities. However if you want lower risk/higher appreciation and are willing to give up some cash flow, you will want to look into more east coast markets like D.C. Boston etc.

640K goes a lot farther in the secondary markets than DC or Boston. It's really difficult to see any properties cash flow without significant down payment on DSCR loans in the DC metro area, but you're right on regarding appreciation.

I saw a 4 unit in Pittsburgh with a purchase price of 340K and it was beautiful.  It brought in 4400 per month.  Same property in DC would be over a million, but would bring in probably 8k (if you can find one that wasn't converted to condos).

Yeah the rust belt are basically a bond fixed income but no upside, D.C. is more of a high growth stock low payout now more later though also the paradoxically an extremely safe place to park your money. 

"Rust belt has no upside " You obviously have not been paying attention the last10 years. Pricing has more than doubled, tripled or more in the Cleveland markets. Forbes had Cleveland as the #1 rental market for 17 - 18, but they too were not paying attention. We used to be able to get 25- 30% or more NET caps with pricing from 30- 35k SF, and 10k per unit for MF. Now 10% net caps are to be had with pricing from 90kish, SF and 45-65k MF. per unit. Even 2021 Forbes still has the Cleveland markets in the top 5. I just recently picked up a SF 3/2 in a nice area all in 63k, values 125k, rent will be about $1350. 4 unit all in 130k, rents will be 750/ 850 per unit. 10 UNIT all in 350k, rents will be about 90k gross with a net of about 60k, 17% net ish. 4 unit all in 115k, rents will be not less than 800 each. 

Its ALL about knowledge and your team

Good luck 

With those sort of numbers I would bare even need lending!
I have no problem investing in the so called “cashflow” markets with less appreciation assuming I can force appreciation enough to refinance out the bulk of my capital 

Post: Where should I buy a multi-family for $1.6M?

Ryan SpearmanPosted
  • Auckland, New Zealand
  • Posts 80
  • Votes 36
Quote from @Bob Stevens:
Quote from @Ryan Spearman:
Quote from @Phommala Songkhors:

Red - landlord friendly states, not to get political, but its in our best interest. 

100+ units. The more units the better, you can use your 1.6 M as a downpayment, Creative is the way to go ! 

I’d love to have a $1.6m down payment but 1.6 would be total purchase price. I’m aiming to have $640k as down payment. 
$1.6m down payment on the next one!

I have been working with out of the country investors for about 10 years and have yet to find any bank that will finance them. They all say you must have a US address and bank account. So I am not sure how you are getting funding? 

I have spoken to a couple of lenders that will do it using my US lawyers address and a Mercury.com bank account. 
The rates aren’t as nice as a regular bank and you need to put 40% down, but it’s still leverage 

Post: Where should I buy a multi-family for $1.6M?

Ryan SpearmanPosted
  • Auckland, New Zealand
  • Posts 80
  • Votes 36
Quote from @Michael P.:

Is it true Australia is better than New Zealand? Somebody told me that.

 What’s Australia?