im in Holladay and thats what I get for one of my duplex rentals, about thee same size. 3 bed 1.5 bath, very dated though.
Ill tell you a quick story.
IT was previously rented for 1995/month. That was a 50 yr old established couple with a college aged kid. Its a very specific rental as the full bath is essentially a jack and jill off the master with the other entrance in the hallway next to the 2 other bedrooms. 1/2 bath is upstairs and basement has no bath.
Advertised it for awhile at 2000, didn't really get a lot of bites. dropped to 1850, got some people interested but no one I wanted to live next to(owner/occupied at the time) Dropped it to 1700 and the flood gates opened and I have the best renters in there I could imagine.
I spent over 3 months trying to rent it, a lot of which was because I wanted to pick my neighbors for the sake of my wife and I have a newborn. I was super super picky.
With that said I could have rented it at 1850 about 2 weeks after I dropped the price from 2000, which I held onto for over a month. I mean it rented really fast last time so why not now????
Holding on as long as I did cost for over $3500 in revenue to where it would of if started back at $1850. That $150 difference will take 2 YEARS to make up! Live and learn right?
with 2600sqft 3 bed and ONLY 1.5 bath it takes a situation like the first renters I had or a group of very close frineds who don't mind sharing a bathtub. I understand that now
Lesson learned.
Take pets on a selective basis. 1/2 your renters have animals.
Do 1/4ly inspections(which you should be doing already) to look for pet damage(and to change furnace filters).
Feel your tenant out during walkthrough. If you think you can get away with a pet fee then charge it.
You are not bound by any fair housing acts or animal rights acts as you don't have the required amount of rentals to put you in that category.
Hope this helps.
And if you want to sell it....here I am:)