Hi @Tithi Mehta, the cardinal rule of real estate investing is to have positive cashflow. Having positive cashflow enables you to fund reserves and to hold on to the property indefinitely which gives you time to allow the magic of leverage, appreciation and debt pay down take effect. Here are my suggestions:
1) Refinance the loan to get a lower rate and thereby lower your payments. Can you consider not increasing the loan balance to further boost your cashflow
2) Evaluate market rents by talking to brokers and looking on sites like renotmeter.com and if your tenants are below market you can have a conversation that brings their rent up but still keeps them in the property. Vacancy is a real cashflow killer
3) If after refinancing and potentially increasing rents you still don’t have adequate cashflow to fund reserves and property management (you will need this at some point in order to scale) you might consider selling the property and rolling the funds into better cashflow markets
4) Investing out of state - there are many markets across the US with positive cashflow and good appreciation potential and Orlando is certainly one of those, maybe with more of a bias on appreciation than cashflow. Pick one market and go deep into that market to understand the dynamics and to build relationships. David Greene has an excellent book on out of state investing
5) Consider your goals - buying single family homes implies that you have got the time to be actively involved in a real estate business. If you are an accredited investor you can also consider investing passively in syndicates which gives all of the benefits of investing directly yourself (cashflow, appreciation, favorable tax treatment) in return for a reasonable fee.
Good luck!