Let's compare: (...with just some made-up, fantasy scenerios!)
1. Paying 50K cash net for a house, and owner financing it out.
or
2. Paying 50K cash net for the same house, and renting it out.
Let's assume the house needs 8K in rehab in order to make it rent-able.
Under the "buy & owner finance" scenario. You may get by, let's say with a smaller rehab tab of 4K (as you could express to the "buyer prospect" that you just did 4k worth of rehab) and leave the other 4K "on the table", as a bargaining chip.
Let's assume the house has an "after repaired appraisal value" of $75,000.
Hold out for a buyer with at least 20% down or at least $15,000 (try to get a little more, like "if the buyer gives you $2000 more down, you will match the 2K and do the extra 4k in rehab work! or just try to get a little more than 20%).
Why this may be important? Well now you may have a solid mortgage and note with almost 23% ($17,000) as a down payment! Will make the note much easier to sell if over 22% down, for sure!
Let's say to do a $58,000 15 year "note & mortgage" at 7.5%, which relates to a $537.67 payment.
Your investment was $50,000 net for a house, plus 6K in rehab, for a total of $56,000.
You have banked $15,000 ($17,000 minus $2,000 of the buyer's down payment, that you used towards the 8K rehab).
Plus, you will receive $537.67, possibly for 180 months or 15 years! ($6,452.04 yearly or a total of $96,780.60 in monthly payments.).
Or how about just selling the note?
Let's say after a few months (let's say 6 months, you sell this note at a $6000 discount.)
Because you collected more than 20% down that has an attractive interest rate (7.5%) for a notebuyer and a 15 year note (that is now "seasoned to", let's say 14 1/2 years to maturity) is also attractive to a notebuyer!
You will collect the following:
$ 52,000.00 cash for the note
$ 03,226.02 cash (6 monthly payments of $537.67)
$ 15,000.00 cash - down payment banked
$ 70,226.02 cash in 6 months.
You invested $56,000 and received just about 29% return (or a $20,226.02) profit in six months! No too shabby!
Or just keep the buyer, for as long as 15 years!
You already have $15,000 of your $56,000 investment back.
So you are collecting $6,452.04 a year on a $41,000 net investment ($50,000 net + $6,000.00 rehab, minus $15,000 down = $ 41,000.00), for 15 years!
Now let's look at renting:
Let's guess that "market rent" for this house is $750.
You got 58K in cash already invested, plus the annual property taxes, insurance and the ongoing possibility of major repairs, future tenant damage, vacancy periods, possible future assessments, future code violations, etc. Plus no guarantee of getting "long term tenants", plus all the other "land lording" issues that can pop up, ...and then a strong possibility of repainting, new carpets and more, every few years or so, until you find that "long-term tenant".
...for $750 per month!
You have a 75K asset that you paid 58K for. So that's good and you have gross rental income of $9,000 per year
Both ways can be rewarding and a as Brian Hancock artfully expressed, "a number of things may happen", which could cloud-up your returns (and your sanity too! lol!)
Me? I really like having that "$15,000 cushion"
Happy New Year to all!
Bob Dobbs
Land Rescue League